That may be a bit of an over simplification of my feelings about Buffy. On one hand, I love her as the heroine of her own show and someone who repeatedly saved the world. But on the other hand, she is just portrayed as being so incredibly self-involved that it’s really maddening to me. Throughout the last few seasons I felt like she was fantastically off-target and inconsistent while making moralistic speeches to the rest of the Scoobies. But yes, she was the focus of the group and what brought them all together.I remember from reading fb in the WTTV thread that you don't like Buffy.
I saw the similarities between this story and One Tin Soldier as soon as I read it. I have to give a shout-out to Chris who once proposed a simple theme series for our group that had something like a birth, a death, and a decision or something like that. I liked the idea, particularly at this time of year.I just love the motif of "One life ends, another begins". I saw it in "One Tin Soldier" and loved it there, almost as much as I loved it here.
Absolutely. The Jewish tradition calls for naming a child after a dead relative (in this case, making the exception for a non-relative). I’m named after an aunt, my brother for our Grandfather, and my son for my mother. To Willow, I would imagine it would be requisite. And I tried Anne Joyce R M and thought it sounded totally wrong.And by giving their new baby Joyce's first name and Buffy's middle name, I get the sense that Willow and Tara are making sure that they live on, at least in some form.
Thanks so much.
Michelle –
Of that list, I’m most pleased with reaffirming. I was a little worried that this was too long and too much of loss before the Better Days part at the end. I also really toyed and troubled over putting in some overt statement of the theme: death and birth, miracles, etc. but decided to leave it for the reader to feel and I’m incredibly happy to see that it seems to have worked. Thanks for that.Beautiful, charming, sad, reaffirming.
I thought it would be fun and honestly thought it would be a little more obscure but you Kittens are so darn smart that you picked it up right off. That’s actually why Chris traded places with me and I’m grateful to him.I enjoyed how you sprinkled the other Songs of Christmas throughout this tale. It was a nice way to tie them all together.
I mentioned this in my feedback to Cam in the MT thread. It’s something I feel that I’m just learning as a writer. I think that I started using the technique consciously in SAI, then MT, then Waiting, and now here. You’re right about what I left out and I wanted the reader asking those exact questions. I wanted to have a few lines about the toll in specific injuries that had been visited on this group but I didn’t want to explain how it happened.One of the things about your writing that I find fascinating as well as frustrating is your ability to tell a story that is compelling and complete without giving the reader all of the details.
Yes. It seems to me that season 4 is very much about finding yourself as an individual and then season 5 is about coming back together to family. And I think that for most of us, that’s a big part of what we’ve found in life.That's what life is really all about, isn't it? Finding yourself surrounded by a family of your own choosing - a group of people whom you love and who love you in return.
I totally understand what you’re saying. She wouldn’t be a human if she didn’t break at some point and it wouldn’t be healthy for her to hold it inside.This may sound a bit strange, but it was nice (hmm...that may not be the right word, but I can't think of another) to see Tara buckle under the strain.
Thank you so much for the praise.Throughout this series the RKT writer's have truly captured the true meaning of the holiday (whichever one you personally prescribe to). Thanks so much for helping to restore my faith in humanity, if only for a little while.
Happy Holidays to you.
Dianneswillowtree – Thanks. Yes, Buffy definitely knew what she meant to her family. Thanks so much.
watty – Hello.
Oh yes. Very wrong.From the moment Tara woke up there was a general feeling of lethargy, of something wrong. Then Willow in a cast, black eye and 7 stitches made me realize something was very wrong.
Definitely. Don’t you ever get that feeling? That if you can turn on enough lights or TV or radio or something, you won’t be alone and bereft? Anyway, thank you for your thoughts about the roll call (as it were) and various details of injuries.Can't help feeling that she was overcompensating, or trying to get over of something.
Yes, Willow’s Buffy’s first friend and first civilian involved. I would say that she was abducted by the male vampire rather than Darla but that’s splitting hairs I think. Yes, Tara’s been holding everyone together as a sort of mother figure while Anya helped out by doing the tasks she can.
Thank you. I agree. I also like the way it finally allows Willow to come to life and color in this story. You know?even the scene after everyone has left when she breaks down ... it made me feel her strength rather than her weakness.
Mmm. I hadn’t thought of a fade-in/fade-out but that’s a good description. I thought about different titles but decided that simple worked best. Thanks.
I’m glad to hear (read) you say that. As I was writing I really hoped that it would be a powerful and effective finale. Thank you.Couldn't have asked for a more moving and fitting finale to our series
Thank you.
highlandlass25 – Please, cry away. Thank you.
Emms – Well. For now, thank you and I’ll see if you’ve edited by tomorrow when I post. Thanks.
Kaia – Yay for the lump in your throat. When I read your story, I was just amazed at the similarities between the two. And I found it fascinating and yet not at all that they stepped on each other’s toes or anything. I loved yours and found mine to be different also.
I couldn’t tell you another song they sing either but I’ve heard this one on the radio a lot last year and really love it.I had no idea the GooGoo Dolls sang "Better Days".
Thanks. I’ve never thought that so much: that I no longer get the same feedback that I used to because everyone is so used to me. Interesting. Thanks so much.
taralicious – Hello. Thanks so much. I’m glad that the story was intriguing. I wanted it to pull the reader in without being cheap about it. I like the way you word it:
That’s a good description.Until you wove into the narrative how each member was accounted for.
And I can’t possibly say something more appropriate about dealing with Joyce’s death and then Buffy’s than you’ve written. Thank you for that.
Thank you for your amazing feedback.
Justin – Hi, Justin! I’m glad you like the decision to leave the details of the battle to the reader. As I was saying above, I feel that I’m just starting to learn how to leave so much unsaid an let the reader invent it him/herself. It can be much worse that way.
Thank you.
[/center]
[/center]


