TITLE: Donegal Street
AUTHOR: Wayland
RATING: PG-13
DISCLAIMER: Willow, Tara and any other characters from the Buffy the Vampire Slayer franchise belong to Joss Whedon, FOX and ME.
SPOILERS: Up to and including Season Six.
SUMMARY: Tara left Willow after Tabula Rasa. It is now about a year later.
FEEDBACK: I would be grateful for your comments.
NOTES: Thanks to my beta, Vivienne, for the encouragement I needed to get this far. Thanks to BeMyDeputy for invaluable input.
Chapter 8
Willow stood in the kitchen doorway, trying to remember what she was doing there. Her brain felt congealed. She couldn’t think. Her gaze wandered over the sink and the pile of draining crockery before stopping at the coffee maker. A rush of relief filled her. Something she could do. She walked forward, reached up to open the cupboard in front of her, and pulled out a bag of ground coffee. She placed two matching mugs beside the machine and grinned foolishly at the sight. Willow felt her head was like the inside of a pinball machine. The rapid ricocheting of her emotions left her slightly stunned. Ten minutes ago the pain had been so bad she’d felt like vomiting. Now, she was arranging coffee cups and smiling like an idiot.
A moment later, Willow’s hand jerked and she spilled coffee grains in an arc over the kitchen counter. Her heart beat wildly. It took a split second before she registered what had startled her. The house phone, ringing. She looked down helplessly at the mess in front of her, then wiped her hand on her jeans and went out to the hall.
‘Hello?’
In Sunnydale, Buffy had spent the last half hour practising a breezy, nonchalant tone.
‘Will! How are you this fine Sundayish Sunday morning?’
The brief silence that followed made her wince. Too much. She sounded like Xander. On drugs.
‘Um. Hi Buffy. I’m fine, thanks.’
Buffy clenched her teeth and took a long breath through her nose. That phrase again. ‘I’m fine.’ She had come to loathe it over the last year. The firm, cheerful tone in which those words were always delivered grated, like sandpaper on her skin. Willow had the most expressive face. Every emotion she felt was readable in her fine features and large, green eyes. Beautifully transparent. It was a quality that Buffy found endearing. But lately . . . well, lately, Willow’s face was like a fogged-up window, all it revealed was your own reflection. Buffy felt a familiar mixture of sadness and guilt.
Tough love. Despite the general belief, Buffy hadn’t slept through all her classes. She knew an oxymoron when she heard one. Willow had needed love, without the adjective. And Buffy had failed her.
‘Tara’s here.’
‘What?’
Willow’s sudden announcement interrupted her train of thought and startled her into a sharper response than she’d intended.
‘I haven’t hurt her!’ The panicked fear in Willow’s voice brought tears to Buffy’s eyes.
‘Of course not! I wasn’t thinking that! I was just . . . surprised, that’s all.’
‘Oh . . . right. She didn’t say she was coming?’ Willow’s tone was now calm, even slightly offhand, as if she were embarrassed by her outburst.
‘No. I mean yes, I mean . . . . ’ Buffy paused to gather her thoughts. When she had given Tara Willow’s address the other day she hadn’t really expected her to head straight for the city. The idea that her own ill-tempered outburst might have provoked this action made her feel queasy. On the other hand, any contact between the pair had to be an improvement – right? Suddenly, Buffy realised that Willow was waiting in silence for her to continue and felt a pang of nostalgia for the days when getting a word in edgeways with her friend was a rare achievement.
‘So . . . . ’ Buffy played for time, considering, and then abandoning, several light-hearted comments. The realisation that she was afraid to say what was on her mind – to Willow of all people – saddened her, and she didn’t like the feeling. She forced herself to continue.
‘Look . . . I know that me giving relationship advice is a bit like a butcher addressing the Annual Vegan Convention, but . . . maybe you guys need to talk?’
More silence. Buffy bit her lip, determined to wait it out. When Willow finally replied, her voice was small and hesitant.
‘But I don’t know how.’
Buffy closed her eyes and gripped the phone tightly, until a warning creak of plastic made her loosen her fingers. It was the most honest thing she had heard Willow say in months. Buffy wished she were there in person so that she could wrap her arms around her friend.
‘You will. Trust me.’ Buffy wondered if Willow was nodding on the other end of the line, or shaking her head in irritation. She couldn’t tell. There was only silence. Frustration at the distance between them filled her, once again.
‘I love you Will.’
Tara put one hand against the bathroom door and slid the bolt slowly with the other, careful not to make a sound. In her rush earlier she had left her clean clothes in the bedroom. Now she wanted the security of being fully dressed before facing her ex-girlfriend. She tiptoed into the hallway. The first thing she saw was Willow, perched on a chair, leaning into the phone in her hand.
‘I love you too.’
Tara reached out to the wall, suddenly weak from the jealousy that exploded in her stomach and spread throughout her body, heating her face.
I have no right to feel this way. None.Willow replaced the phone in its cradle and looked up. She smiled when she saw Tara.
‘Hi. Good shower?’
Tara just nodded in reply, knowing that she could hardly swallow, much less speak. Willow waved at the phone without breaking her gaze.
‘You just missed Buffy. I can call her back, if you like. She can’t have gone far.’
Tara frowned in confusion, unable to process.
Buffy? Willow frowned back at her.
‘No, I’m a dummy. Your hair is all wet and you’re probably catching a chill, standing here in the hall. What am I thinking?’
Tara felt herself smiling as relief rushed through her. It was just Buffy. Not a new . . . anybody…just Buffy. Of course. Willow had said . . . hadn’t she? Then thoughts of her last meeting with the Slayer intruded and she felt a kind of dread. Tara kept her smile in place by an act of will. Her face burned hotter.
For a long, happy moment, Willow just looked at her. Tara was wrapped in a fluffy, wine-red towel, part of a set that Willow had bought when she first came to the city and never used. The dark colour contrasted with the pale cream of her bare shoulders. Her hair, wet and darkened from the shower, was slicked back. This brought into prominence her features - the clear blue of her eyes, the plumpness of her lips, the deep flush of her cheeks . . . Willow jerked and almost fell off the narrow hall seat. She had been staring, really staring.
‘I’m sorry.’
‘I - I’m sorry.’
The tension of the moment snapped in the clash of their apologies. Tara giggled. It sounded wonderful. Willow’s face ached with the unfamiliar stretch of a wide grin.
It felt good. It felt amazing. Tara was still smiling, then she shivered as a cool breeze crossed the hallway. With apparent reluctance, she gestured towards the guest room.
‘I’d better . . . . ’
‘Wait, wait.’
Willow jumped up and dashed past Tara, disappearing into her own bedroom. She returned a moment later, slightly breathless, clutching a hairdryer. She held it out to Tara with both hands, like an offering.
‘Don’t want you to catch cold.’
‘I think that’s actually a myth,’ Tara responded gravely, the corner of her mouth twitching slightly.
Willow’s tone was equally serious, ‘That is a possibility, I admit, but it’s no reason to avoid sensible precautions.’
Tara took the dryer and Willow watched her until she had disappeared into the guestroom. Then she went into the bathroom and quickly yanked the white hand towel off its rail and threw it into the laundry basket. Opening the cupboard, she pulled out a small, dark-red towel and smoothed it in place on the rail. She gave it a satisfied nod before heading back to the kitchen to continue preparing breakfast.
************
Willow paused to inspect the carefully laid table. Two places were set, opposite each other. Each comprised a small plate, a glass, a mug and silverware. In the centre of the table was a basket of bagels, wrapped in a napkin to keep warm. A jug of juice was to the side, next to a pot of freshly made coffee. Two small china dishes contained cream cheese and blackcurrant jelly. A bowl of fresh fruit completed the ensemble. She nudged Tara’s knife and fork so that they overlapped at a slight angle. Disrupting the geometric precision of the setting offended her, but maybe it looked more casual . . . ? She didn’t want it to seem as if she was trying to impress Tara. She was, of course and she had no trouble admitting that to herself. She would do anything to persuade the woman to stay a day longer, an hour longer, even. But if it were too obvious Tara might feel pressured. ‘
I need to go.’ The words made her stomach churn. She was grateful for the distraction of a sudden silence which signalled that Tara had turned off the hair dryer. Willow could picture the scene from long familiarity. Tara would have her head dipped, her long hair brushed up from the back and draped over, concealing her features completely. Tara always dried her hair that way and Willow always greeted her with a smile and a ‘Hey you.’ when she tossed back her head and revealed her beautiful face. Willow dragged her mind back to the present. Cloth napkins were definitely too formal. Kitchen towel would suffice. Should she tear off two pieces and fold them into triangles or just leave the roll on the table? Or neither, and then if Tara got fruit juice or jelly on her fingers she might just lick it off, which would be . . . which would be . . . not good for her sanity, Willow concluded wryly. She leaned over and straightened Tara’s knife and fork, then looked up to see the woman herself, smirking at her.
‘There’s nothing wrong with being neat!’ Willow pouted.
‘I didn’t say a word.’ Tara’s smirk was still in place.
It was so easy to fall into old patterns, the childish teasing, the silly faces. So easy and so very confusing. Willow picked up the coffee pot and concentrated on the suddenly difficult task of pouring.
‘Hungry?’
‘I am a little peckish, yes.’
And that was one of Giles’s expressions, one they had both appropriated. Willow saw that her knuckles were white. She wasn’t sure if she could keep this up. She focused on filling the other mug, fussing a little until the dark liquid had reached its optimum level. She half expected another teasing comment from Tara and was both relieved and disappointed at the sober ‘Thank you’ she received as Tara pulled out a chair and sat down.
Tara took an apple from the bowl and then held it awkwardly in her hand as Willow sat down opposite her and launched into a detailed explanation of what was for breakfast, although it was perfectly self-evident. Tara swallowed the smart remark she’d been about to make and simply nodded her thanks. She’d felt off-balance since the phone call and now she told herself to calm down. Enough teasing or flirting or whatever the hell it was that she’d been doing. Enough. Tara felt a sense of unreality as she complimented the food and responded to Willow’s questions formally. Would she like a bagel? Yes, she would, thank you. No, one would be plenty, thanks again. They sounded like work colleagues, breakfasting together in a hotel. When Willow stopped talking Tara finally placed the apple on her plate and began to slice it into quarters. She removed the core and, in an automatic gesture, set one piece of the fruit on Willow’s plate. Then she caught herself.
‘S-sorry . . . . ’ Tara could feel herself blushing, but Willow just smiled, popped the apple in her mouth and muttered a muffled, ‘Thanks.’
Tara felt the tension leave her body as she watched Willow chew with exaggerated relish. After a moment’s hesitation she followed suit, crunching enthusiastically, and shamelessly talking with her mouth full.
‘Keeps the doctor away.’
Willow raised an eyebrow.
‘I think that’s actually a myth.’ Her tone was sympathetic, as if letting Tara down gently.
Tara narrowed her eyes. ‘Says you.’
‘Says me.’ Willow poked her tongue out for good measure, and Tara felt a thrill of fear as she laughed.
So much for the not flirting. . . .************
They were almost finished eating. The last few sips of her coffee had been cold. Tara realised that she was dragging out the meal, reluctant to get up from the table. This was madness. She had classes to get back to. She ought to be looking up the train times, not covertly studying the woman opposite her. Willow was scraping the remaining smears of jelly from her plate with a crust of a bagel. Her brow was furrowed in an endearing expression, as if the job required all of her concentration.
‘What was it like?’ The words escaped Tara’s mouth without any conscious intent to voice them.
‘What was what like?’ Willow’s face was a picture of confusion and Tara realised the apparent randomness of her question.
She was about to speak and then a memory came back to her, sharp and clear. That one time a fox had scratched a hole in the chicken shed wall and the birds had escaped all over the yard. She and Donnie had spent hours searching for the eggs, crawling under the barn and between the closely packed hedges which bordered the lower field. She remembered catching a glimpse of a plump, brown beauty which had slipped down between entangled roots. She had leaned in, off-balance, stretching for it, until her fingertips touched the grainy curves of the shell. And then, a sickening crunch and the feel of sticky, slimy wetness on her hand.
Willow had raised her eyebrows in cheerful puzzlement. Here was her opportunity. She could ask about something else. Something safe. Anything that would preserve this perfect, fragile peace a little longer.
Again, the words seemed to emerge, unbidden.
‘Giving up magic. What was it like?’
Willow’s reaction filled Tara with instant, bitter remorse. She flinched, her skin turning red and then white. She took a breath that hissed between her teeth. She looked down at her hands, apparently surprised at the sight of the piece of bread she was twisting with her fingers. She dropped it onto the plate and then looked up. She met Tara’s gaze, unblinking. When she began to speak her words were slow, as if she were reading from an unfamiliar text.
‘From what I’ve read, it was kind of like coming off alcohol. The shakes, sweats, aching and itching. Lots of throwing up, not so much sleeping.’ Willow shrugged and said lightly, ‘No DTs though. I got lucky there - nothing crawling out of the walls.’ Tara sat very still until Willow stopped looking around the room and finally faced her.
‘Please Willow, tell me what it was really like. I need to know.’
She could see the battle waging in Willow’s eyes, in the struggle to meet her gaze.
Tara felt herself buckling, as if a tremendous weight was pressing on her. The strain was almost more than she could bear. Then, at last, Willow spoke.
‘Agony. It was agony.’
For a moment, the murmured words seemed to fill the room. Then Willow took in a long, shuddery breath and squared her shoulders.
‘I kept reliving what I’d done, over and over. But that wasn’t the worst thing, not then . . . I was so scared, all the time. I couldn’t stop thinking. I couldn’t sit still. My head felt like it would burst, the thoughts kept going round and round . . . . ’ She trailed off, her long fingers picking at a loose thread on her jeans, her eyes vacant.
‘What were you afraid of?’ Tara’s voice was a gentle nudge.
Willow looked up. ‘Everything. Nothing. You know those seconds when a vamp appears and you aren’t quite sure where Buffy is? It was like that, only the seconds went on and on and there was no vamp and no Buffy. Just me. I was afraid of myself, of my own mind.’
Tara forced herself to stay silent - to wait for Willow to continue.
‘The first two nights I watched the clock, literally every minute. I’d take off my shoes and get into bed and swear that I was going to stay there for at least five minutes. I’d last two, maybe three, then I’d get up again and put my shoes back on and pace up and down my room. Then I’d try it again. The third night I slept, and after an hour I woke up. I was terrified. I vomited. It was so quick, I didn’t make it to the bathroom.’ Willow forced a smile. It twisted in Tara’s chest. ‘That’s when the not eating came in kind of handy.’
Willow continued, speaking more quickly now, tripping over her words.
‘The fear . . . it wasn’t about the magic. It wasn’t really the magic I wanted. I mean, I did want it. Craved it. I knew it would stop me thinking, it would shut my head up. But not enough and not for long. And when it wore off, it would be worse. And I couldn’t even imagine worse. So, magic - not really an option. Actually, a coma sounded pretty good at the time.’
Now the self-mocking note was back, as if to make amends for her previous display of emotion. Willow’s tone was dry, in deliberate anti-climax.
‘Anxiety is a symptom of withdrawal. Apparently.’
She looked at Tara as if expecting a response. Tara managed a slight nod, but no words. Willow took a breath and continued.
‘When I started sleeping it got easier. During the day I could kind of hang on. And they worked out a schedule to keep me company. Buffy and Xander . . . but Dawn was the best.’
‘Dawn!’ Tara hadn’t meant to interrupt. She winced apologetically, but Willow didn’t seem put out.
‘Yeah, I know, Dawn. She was so mad at me. The others - every time they looked at me I could see the embarrassment, like I was a reminder of something they wanted to forget. I mean, they were great, don’t get me wrong, but Dawn, she didn’t feel guilty and she didn’t feel sorry for me, she was just plain angry. Buffy made her sit with me and she bitched up a storm. I don’t think she ever asked me how I was feeling, not once. She said I might as well make myself useful so we spent hours doing her homework. It helped a lot, having something to concentrate on - it slowed my head down. And when she got straight A’s, I felt a tiny bit useful.’
Willow stopped abruptly and turned to Tara, an earnest expression on her face.
‘I didn’t do the work for her or anything, I just explained stuff.’ Tara had to smile. Willow Rosenberg had been capable of a criminally reckless rampage, but cheating on schoolwork was still unthinkable.
‘You felt better because she was horrible to you?’ Tara’s voice was tentative. She didn’t want Willow to stop talking, but she needed to understand. Willow furrowed her brow. It took her a few moments to answer.
‘No, not exactly . . . when I was with her I didn’t feel so . . . broken. Selfish and stupid, yes, deserving of her very vocal contempt, yes . . . but still Willow, you know?’ Tara managed a small nod in reply. ‘Xander and Buffy . . . I could see they were afraid, like if they looked at me the wrong way, or said the wrong thing, I’d shatter. To Dawn, I was just a screw up.’ A faint smile tugged at the corner of Willow’s mouth. ‘I needed to pull myself together. To stop acting like an idiot, cuz she was really, really pissed.’ The smile faded. ‘And of course . . . .’ Willow looked away.
‘What?’
‘Nothing.’
‘Please, Willow.’
With obvious reluctance, Willow continued.
‘She blamed me for you leaving. Rightly so.’
‘No, that was my decision.’
‘I gave you no choice.’
Tara shook her head. She didn’t want to argue, not now. She thought back to those awkward meetings with Dawn.
‘It’s funny, every time I saw her, she said how well you were doing.’
‘Really?’ Willow frowned, clearly trying to make sense of that. ‘Well, she probably hoped -’
‘No,’ Tara cut across her. ‘She meant it. She was proud of you.’
Both women paused. Willow spoke first.
‘Little Dawnie, hey?’
‘Yeah.’
In the silence that followed, the weight of Willow’s words began to sink in. Tara reeled. She’d had no idea it had been that bad. Buffy hadn’t told her any of this. Not a word. Neither had Dawn. Out of loyalty, because Willow wouldn’t want her to know? Maybe. Because Tara didn’t want to hear it? Perhaps. Tara knew she had deflected every mention of her ex-girlfriend. Had they understood why?
She could justify why she’d left. Even now. Willow was drowning, kicking and thrashing and pulling Tara under the water with her. Destroying them both. Leaving was the only way she could survive.
But afterwards, when Willow was beaten; when she wasn’t fighting anymore, just drowning? Then, she should have gone back. She should have held her tight and pulled her to the shore. The friends she had betrayed were there, even the girl she had injured.
Why didn’t I go back? Why wasn’t she by Willow’s side, holding and comforting her through those agonizing days and nights? It was her place, wasn’t it?
After Glory, Tara knew that Willow had fought to get her out of the hospital, to take her home where she could care for her. In her lover’s mind, that was her job and no one else’s.
In sickness and in health. Willow had not hesitated. Why hadn’t she done the same?
When Tara left, she’d told herself that it wasn’t for her sake alone. Losing her might shock Willow out of the madness. It might save her. But she didn’t believe that. When Buffy told her about Dawn’s injury, she knew. It wasn’t enough. She wasn’t enough. In a strange way, Willow had come to her senses at last. The borrowed time Tara had been living on was over. And so she had shut down. Given up the woman she loved with barely a fight. And left her to drown.
The realisation hit Tara like a fist. The fear that she wasn’t good enough, the endless waiting for Willow to wake up - finally wake up and see that - had been with her for so long. In the end, the fear had been self-fulfilling.
She had felt unworthy of Willow and because of that, she had failed her.
Tara abruptly came back to her surroundings. Willow was twisting the hem of her shirt, awkward in the long silence. She looked ready to bolt. A thousand words jostled for space in Tara’s mind, she didn’t know where to begin. The silence stretched a little longer. Finally the words came.
‘I’m sorry.’
Willow shook her head vigorously. ‘No, no. It was my fault. Entirely self-inflicted. That’s why I didn’t . . . . ’ She waved her hands in frustration.
‘I’m sorry.’ Tara said again. Something in her tone halted the stream of denials on Willow’s lips. She blinked twice. Her green eyes glistened. When she spoke, her voice was barely a whisper.
‘So am I.’
************