TITLE: Different Roads
AUTHOR: Kirk Baldridge
E-MAIL: KirkBwriter@juno.com
FEEDBACK: Yes, please. The more the better.
DISTRIBUTION: You want it? Take it. Just let me know where it is.
SPOILERS: Nothing, really. It's a speculative story about the past, and the future.
CONTENT: W/T T/f (mentioned) W/f (mentioned)
RATING: PG
DISCLAIMER: I do not own any of these characters. If I did, I'd treat them better than...some people.
SUMMARY: Set well in the future, this is an 'alternate universe story' where Tara left Sunnydale after breaking up with Willow in season six. Many of the other events of season six alternatively happened without her, but not neccessarily the same way they did on the show. All will, hopefully, be explained.
NOTE: It should be pointed out that this story is in no way related to my last one, DARK FUTURE. Yes, it deals with Sunnydale in the future, but that is where the similarities end.
NOTE 2: While this story focuses primarily on Tara, and as you might expect will ultimately end up with her and Willow getting back together, many years have gone by. It would not be realistic if they stayed all alone and miserable during that time now would it? So be warned, if the mere idea of Willow or Tara having been in a relationship with anyone else bothers you, do NOT read this story.
*****
Tara Maclay sat in the bay window of her apartment, looking out over the rain-soaked streets of New York. She had been there for quite some time. Thinking. Remembering.
The thirty-four year old's blonde hair had been cut particularly short. It was a rash decision she had made only a week or so ago. She regretted it almost immediately. That was the final straw in a depressingly long series of bad decisions she had made.
There was a framed photograph in her lap which she knew epitomized her mistakes. It was a picture of her and a beautiful, dark-skinned brunette women with their arms around one another. Her name was Monica Wheeler, and she had been the single brightest light in Tara's life for the past two years.
It was over now. Their relationship. Monica had packed up her things and moved out a month ago. There was no single reason why they broke up; just a lot of little ones that added up to being far more of a headache than either one of them wanted to put up with anymore.
That part of her life was over now. Tara knew and accepted that. But Monica's departure had opened a door into her past she had closed and tried to forget long ago. It would have to be dealt with before she could move on. She got up and walked into the bedroom, sitting the picture of her and Monica down on the desk beside a plane ticket for a flight that very afternoon.
To Sunnydale.
*****
It was a long flight from New York to California, and less than an hour into it Tara curled up in her seat and fell asleep. She dreamt, not surprisingly, about the past.
"Funny shapes, or..." Tara was interrupted by the opening of the back door. She and Dawn turned, to see Willow stumbling into the kitchen with another woman. One Tara did not recognize. They were laughing and smiling, and the blonde felt her chest constricting.
"Tara." Willow was clearly caught off-guard by her presence. "What are you...doing here?"
"I-I...was with Dawn, remember? Our big movie and milkshake fun day?"
The redhead nodded. "Of course."
"We fell as-sleep on the couch, and when w-we w-woke up, you w-weren't...I mean, you and Buffy..."
"She's not home either?" Willow asked.
Tara shook her head.
"Dawnie, I'm sorry. We wouldn't have stayed gone so long if..." Willow's eyes widened as the 'we' reminded her who was standing behind her. The _expression on Tara's face told her exactly what the blonde was thinking. "Tara, I want to introduce you to somebody. This is Amy."
Amy waved, smiling tiredly. "Hi."
"H-Hi," said Tara. "Since you're here, I-I should go..." She started toward the door.
"No, Amy," Willow continued. "Amy the rat?" She turned. "Sorry."
The brunette shook her head. "No, it's fair. I was a rat."
It still took Tara several moments to understand what Willow was telling her. "How did you..."
"I don't know. It just came to me the other day. Isn't this great?"
Tara wasn't sure what to say. The shock turned to sadness and pain as Amy went on to tell her how much magick she and Willow had done the night before. She felt very cold when she heard about the casual abuse of the sacred power, and had to leave. "Dawnie, I'll see you later." This time, Willow tried to stop her by telling her about some clothes she had left behind. She didn't even slow down. "I'll get them later!" She passed Buffy in the hall, ignoring the Slayer as she fought back the tears until she got out of the house.
Tara woke suddenly from her dream, as the flight attendant was asking if she wanted to eat. She ordered a small vegetarian plate and then ran her fingers through what remained of her hair. After that encounter she got called to the office of her art teacher at UC Sunnydale. The woman told her about a year long art study program in Europe, entirely funded by a grant from one of the school's biggest benefactors, which she and several of her art students were planning to participate in. And Tara was one of those students being invited. She was so hurt by Willow, and by how out of control she was getting, that she agreed.
The year in Europe turned into two, then three. Even after her teacher and the other students went back home to the States she stayed. She got an apartment and a job at a restaurant to pay the bills, while she worked on and then finally sold several of her paintings. She was well-respected in her community; not just for her artistic skills, but for her magickal and aura reading abilities. Though she never got rich, monetarily speaking at least, she had more friends and a much better, safer life. At first she stayed in contact with Dawn by e-mail, but eventually the letters got fewer and further between. Eventually they stopped all together.
She moved several times in Europe, sometimes by choice and somtimes because she was no longer financially able to maintain her current residence. The art business was a fickle one, to be sure. At length she got homesick, for the US, and moved to New York to start over. That was where she met Monica, who was managing the gallery where Tara took several of her paintings for an exhibit. Monica bought one, the two of them became friends, and after a few months they became more than friends.
But Tara always remembered Sunnydale. Often at breakfast, if she or Monica were making pancakes, she would recall how she used to make funny shapes for Dawn. And every time a Wiccan day of observance came along she thought about the ceremonies she and Willow had attended.
Even while she was with Monica, Tara never forgot about Willow. The redhead had been her first real girlfriend, and the first woman she ever made love with. Monica knew this. After all these years there was a part of Tara that still loved--and probably always would love--Willow. Monica knew this too. It was a big part of the reason the two of them broke up. She perceived a lack of total commitment, which was too much to deal with, particularly when coupled with Tara's increasing frustration over her art not selling as well in the States. Naturally there were other factors involved as well, but those were two of the biggest.
Tara shook her head as a flight attendant announced they were making preparations to land.
*****
Tara hadn't told anyone she was coming, so she took a cab to Buffy's house.
About halfway there it occured to her that it might not be Buffy's house any longer. It had been nearly ten years since she last spoke to anyone in Sunnydale. Anything could have happened in all that time. Buffy might have lost the house because of debt or demon, or she might have chosen to move for some other reason. The people living there now might have no idea who she was.
But she had to start somewhere.
As they pulled up in front Tara noticed that the house had been repainted dark blue. It looked like parts of it had been recently repaired or refurbished too. She got out and stared.
"Hey, lady?" The driver was opening the trunk to get her bags. "You okay?"
After a moment, Tara nodded. "I'm fine."
"That'll be $22.50. Unless, of course, you want me to take you someplace else?"
"No. This is fine." Tara paid him. "Thank you." Once he was gone she dragged her bags up to the front porch, and took a deep breath as she prepared to knock on the door.
To her surprise, it opened on its own. A tall, dark-haired man in his late twenties or early thirties emerged. He was clearly as startled to see her as she was to see him. "Oh, uhh...hi."
"Hi," said Tara. She had no idea who he was.
"Can I help you with something?"
Tara started. "Oh. Sorry. I was wondering...is this the Summers' residence?"
"Sure is." He cleared his throat. "Hon! Someone's at the door!" He squeezed past Tara. "Excuse me, but I have to go. I'm late for work." He glanced over his shoulder. "Love you."
Tara watched him go, confused. Then she turned back to find someone standing in the door staring at her with a slack jaw and wide eyes. The blonde smiled. "Hey, Dawnie."
The gawky, cute teenager Tara remembered had matured into a tall, beautiful young woman. She had brown hair streaked with blonde that was tied in a nearly waist-length ponytail. She continued to stare until she finally found the strength to speak, and even then it was haltingly.
"Tara?"
"It's me. What?" She smiled. "Do I really look that different?"
Dawn slammed the door right in her face.
*****
Tara was too stunned to move for several moments. While she had not exactly been expecting a warm welcome from Dawn or the others, she hadn't expected this either. As she went to knock on the door it was abruptly jerked open again, and a teary-eyed Dawn stepped out onto the porch.
"How dare you!"
Tara started. "W-What? Dawnie..."
"Don't call me that! Nobody calls me that anymore. My name is Dawn."
"I-I'm sorry."
Dawn crossed her arms. "I guess I owe Spike twenty bucks."
"What?"
"It's been over ten years, Tara. We lost track of you. I said you were dead. Spike bet me you were alive. It looks like he won." Dawn frowned. "So, what do you want?"
Tara shrugged her shoulders. "Nothing. I-I just...I thought..."
"What? That we'd welcome you back with open arms? You abandoned us, Tara. When you left Willow, I knew it was for the best. It hurt, but I knew you were right to do it." Dawn sighed. "But then you ran away. From me, from Willow...from your life and your friends and everything. You quit. And a part of me...quit too. I tried to pretend it didn't bother me, when we talked on the phone, and in the e-mails, but I felt betrayed. Buffy tried to tell me it had nothing to do with me. So did Willow, when she wasn't crying. But I knew that wasn't true. I was one of the things you wanted to forget. That's why it was so easy for you to disappear."
"No. Dawn, I never, ever forgot about you. I told you I would always love you, and I still do."
Dawn wiped her eyes. "Then why did you stop answering my e-mails? Why did you change your address? If you weren't trying to hide...from me, from us, what were you doing?"
"It's complicated. I had a life in Europe. A good one. But that doesn't mean I didn't miss you. All of you. When I moved the first time it wasn't by choice. Then I got busy, and..." Tara shook her head. "No excuses. I owe you that at least. I got busy. Sometimes I forgot, sometimes I didn't have access to a computer or a phone. But I promise I never forgot about you, Dawn. If you believe nothing else, believe that."
"You still haven't answered my question. What are you doing here? What do you want?"
Tara looked around. "I'll tell you everything you want to know. But can we go inside? I don't particularly want to discuss my personal life in front of the whole neighborhood."
*****
Dawn motioned for her to go in first, then frowned when the phone rang.
Much of the furniture was different, Tara noted as she was putting her bags down in the living room. That couch was definitely new. There were also several paintings on a wall where there hadn't been any before, and there was a flat-screen TV hanging on another. She shook her head.
"No, I can't babysit right now," Dawn said to whoever was on the phone. "I'm busy. What? No, Bill's gone. I have company." She glanced over her shoulder. "As a matter of fact, you guys may want to get over here. I think you're going to love this one. Okay, see you in a little while." She hung up.
"Who was that?" Tara asked. "And who's Bill?"
"That was Xander," Dawn replied. "He's on his way. And Bill is my fiancee."
Tara gasped. "You're engaged? That's fantastic. Congratulations. Was that him I met on the way out?"
"That's him. Bill Maxwell. He's studying to be a lawyer."
"A lawyer? Your mom would be proud."
Dawn sat down on the couch, and Tara joined her. "So where have you been all this time?"
"It's a long, complicated, depressing story. If it's all the same to you, since Xander's coming, I'd rather only tell it once." Tara cleared her throat. "Umm...where are Buffy and..."
Dawn's shoulders stiffened, and a lump formed in her throat. "Tara, there's something you should know. Buffy's not with us, anymore."
Tara gasped. "What? How? Was it a demon, or..."
"Nothing like that. This kid wandered out into the road. Buffy went to save him, and she did, but the semi wasn't able to stop in time." Dawn chuckled nervously. "Can you believe it? All those years fighting monsters, vampires, saving the world over and over again, and she gets taken out by a stupid truck."
Tara put her face in her hands. "Oh Goddess."
"We tried to call you. To tell you what happened. But we couldn't find you. I was angry. At you. I hated you. For years I blamed you for not being here for Buffy." Dawn fighed. "But I know it's not your fault. You had to do what you had to do. Besides, if you had been here, you might have died too."
Tara lifted her head. "What about Willow? Is she...?"
"She's alive," said Dawn. "More or less."
"What does that mean?" Tara asked.
Dawn stood up. "I'll tell you later. I heard a car door. I think they're here."
"Who?"
The front door opened. Xander, looking like a slightly older, better dressed version of the young man she once knew, entered--with a two or three year old baby in his arms. He blinked when he saw Tara. "Well well. Look, it's a ghost, Amber. Only the good kind."
A dark-haired woman Tara did not recognize came in behind him. "Honey?"
"Nanc." Xander put an arm around the room. "I'd like you to meet Tara Maclay. She's an old friend of ours. Tara, this is my wife Nancy. And our daughter, Amber."
Tara shook hands with the woman. "Nice to meet you." She smiled at the child. "You too."
"You guys thirsty?" Dawn asked.
Xander and Nancy shook their heads. "Wa-wa!" cried Amber, clapping her hands. "Wa-wa!"
"One wa-wa coming up," said Dawn. "Tara? Wanna help me out?" She walked into the kitchen, with the blonde right behind her. "It's not polite to stare, you know."
"Sorry." Tara shook her head. "When I left, Xander and Anya were engaged. What happened?"
"The wedding sort of went kerflooey. This demon--I think he was one of Anya's old boyfriends, or maybe just a vengeance curse of hers, I'm not sure--he screwed it all up."
"So Xander eventually married someone else. What happened to Anya?"
Dawn shrugged her shoulders. "Good question."
*****
"So, do you own the company now?" Tara asked.
Xander shook his head. "Not exactly. I'm in charge of...well, pretty much everything. But I've still got to answer to the guy who actually owns the place."
"Still, you're really doing well for yourself, Xander. That's great."
"Thanks. Hey, what about you?" Xander asked. "You here on some big art tour? Mrs. Picasso?"
Tara shook her head. "I wish. I haven't sold a painting in months. The art business is changing, and frankly I don't know if I have the strength or resolve to keep up with it."
"So what are you going to do?" said Dawn.
"I don't know. That's why I came back. I wanted to see if my friends were still talking to me."
"Oh come on. No matter what else happens, we'll always be there for you." Dawn put her hand on Tara's. "Forget what I said before. I could never hate you."
Tara sighed. "Goddess. I've missed so much. I'm sorry I wasn't around."
"It's okay," said Dawn. "You're here now. That's what's important."
"Yeah, we can catch you up on everything." Xander's watch beeped at him. "Except, not right now. Damn. Nancy and I have to attend this fund-raiser. Dawn, I know you said..."
Tara stood up. "Look, I'm intruding. You guys need to go, and I'd be in your way, Dawn. Why don't you stay here with Amber, and I'll just go find a hotel room?"
"No," said Dawn. "We have plenty of empty rooms here. It's just me and Bill. You can stay."
Tara shook her head. "N-No. That's okay. It would be...a little weird, I think." Tara picked up her bags and started toward the door. "There's one thing I would like to know. Willow. Where is she?"
Xander glanced at Dawn, who shrugged her shoulders. "Tara, did Dawn tell you what happened?"
"You mean, about Buffy? Yes."
"Willow had an even harder time than the rest of us. The desire to use magic to try and bring Buffy back, it tore her up inside. We thought she was going to lose it." Xander stuck his hands in his pockets. "Without you here, we couldn't get through to her. No one could."
"But where is she now?" Tara asked. "Dawn said she was still alive?"
Xander nodded.
"Guys. I know I haven't been around in a while, but I know stalling when I see it." Tara crossed her arms. "One of you, please tell me where Willow is."
*****
Tara felt a knot growing in her stomach when her cab came to a stop, in front of a scary-looking building with a sign on it that said Sunnydale Psychiatric Hospital.
"Oh Goddess." Xander and Dawn had just given her this address, they hadn't told her what it was or why Willow was there. "N-No. Willow."
The cab driver glanced over his shoulder. "Did you say something, lady?"
"Umm...no. How much do I owe you?"
"Tab comes to $14.50."
Tara nodded. "H-Here." She handed him a twenty. "Keep the change."
"Thanks, lady. You have a good day now."
Tara slipped out of the cab. Xander and Nancy had given her a ride to the nearest hotel, where she found a room and unpacked her things. Soon after she was struck by a sudden need to see Willow, and called for a cab. But now that she was here, the old fears and self-doubt reemerged in full. No matter what condition Willow was in she was still the woman Tara had once loved more than life itself. The woman a part of her still loved and would probably always love, so long as she lived. Still, she was scared. Not of what she would see--she was pretty sure she could handle that--but rather what Willow would see, or not see, in her.
The nurse behind the counter smiled as the blonde came walking up. "Can I help you?"
"I'm here to see..." Tara took a deep breath. "Is there a Willow Rosenberg here?"
"Oh yes, Miss Rosenberg." The nurse picked up a clipboard and scanned it. "She's in Room 223." She pointed to an elevator at the end of the hall. "It's on the next floor."
Tara nodded. "Thank you." She felt tears welling up in her eyes as she waited for the elevator, and once inside it she lay her head back and did her best to repel the rush of emotions within her. "Goddess." Whatever Willow was going through, she would have to be strong for both of them.
*****
As she approached the door of Room 223, she heard a woman's voice. "Mr. Jones, please get off the bed and put your clothes back on. Yes, I'm impressed, now please...thank you."
Tara peered into the room. A redheaded nurse, with her back to the door, was helping a balding, older man back into his robe. She cleared her throat.
"Excuse me." The white-clad woman started to turn. "Do you..."
The woman she had thought was just a nurse was, in fact, Willow. Her eyes widened. "Tara?"
"Will?"
The redhead closed her eyes. "This can't be happening. Not again. I'm past this now." She took a deep breath and turned back to her patient. "Mr. Jones? Are you all right?" He nodded. "You sit down and watch TV. I'll be back to check on you in a little while, all right?" Again he nodded. "Good man. Bye bye now." Without looking at Tara, who followed, she walked out of the room and straight down the corridor to a small office. The blonde got in the room behind her before she could close the door. "Stop it!"
"Will? What's going on? What's wrong?"
"You're not here. You're not here, you can't be. This is all in my imagination."
Tara shook her head. "I am real, Will. It's me. I swear."
"Why now? After all these years?"
"That's kind of a long story."
Willow turned to stare at her now. "What did you do to your hair?"
"Bad day at the salon. What about you? When did you become a nurse?"
"I spent a couple of months in this place after Buffy...you must have seen Dawn or Xander, right? They told you I was here?" Tara nodded. "And about Buffy?" Tara nodded again, and Willow continued. "Anyway, after I got out I decided to take Psychiatry and Psychology classes, and I started to go to nursing school. I got a recommendation from one of the doctors here and the rest, as they say, is history."
"I'm impressed," said Tara. "It looks like you're doing well for yourself."
Willow shrugged her shoulders. "I don't do it for myself. I do it for the people here. They ask for so little, and I have gained so much from them in return. This beats magic any day."
"So, you're happy?" Willow nodded, and Tara smiled. "Then I'm happy for you."
"You know, once upon a time that would have meant so much to me," said Willow. "But you know what? I'm not that little girl anymore. I've grown up and moved on. Like you did." She crossed her arms. "It took me a long time to get over you, Tara. Your leaving tore me up inside, but it also helped me to build myself back up stronger than I ever was before. In a lot of ways, I guess I owe you for that."
Tara nodded. "I-I shouldn't have come. This was a mistake. I-I'm sorry Willow." She turned to leave, only to feel the redhead's hand on her shoulder. "Will..."
"I can't deal with this right now, Tara. I'm working, and this is important to me."
"I know."
"Meet me. After work? We can talk then."
Tara nodded. "Where?"
"Here. In front of the hospital at eight PM? Okay?"
"Okay."
Tara showed up promptly at 7:59 that evening. Willow clocked out, said good-bye to some of her patients, then Tara followed her to the parking lot.
"I'll drive," said the redhead.
"You've got a car?" Tara asked.
Willow directed them to a tan convertible that was at least ten years old. "I call it Old Reliable. I bought it for a song at a repossession auction, and I haven't had a problem with it yet. It's not much to look at, but then I don't go for flash." She opened the driver's door. "It's unlocked."
"I think it's nice," Tara said once they were inside. "I like it. So, where are we going?"
"To get something to eat," Willow replied. "I was thinking, maybe, the Bronze?"
Tara nodded. "That's fine. I am kind of hungry. But why the Bronze?"
"It's not like you may remember." Willow smiled. "Trust me."
*****
When they pulled up in front of the club, Tara noticed immediately that it had been given a face-lift. New paint, a brand new brighter, flashier sign, and lights that actually illuminated the whole area and made it difficult to find any shadows at all within a hundred yards of the door.
"The vampires must hate this place now," Tara said as they approached the door. "It looks like it'd be a whole lot harder for them to feed around here."
Willow, now wearing a tight black skirt and an even tighter red top, laughed. "You'd be surprised." She smiled at the big bald man guarding the door. "Good evening, Alex."
"Hey, Red. Nice to see you. It's been a while."
"Been busy. This is a friend of mine. Tara."
"Nice to meet you," said the blonde.
Alex smiled, revealing he was missing several teeth. "You too. Any friend of Red is welcome here." He opened the velvet rope for them. "You ladies go on in. Have a good time." As they passed, he leaned down and whispered in Willow's ear. His voice carried anyway. "Glad to see you're finally over Emily."
The redhead's cheeks flushed as she glared at him. "Ixnay on the....umm....just hush, okay?"
"Sorry, Red. Didn't know it was a state secret." He turned to a mousy little man who was trying to slip in behind Willow and Tara. "Lou. Do you think I'm blind? Get to the back of the line."
"Is that guy a friend of yours?" Tara asked.
"I spent a lot of time here after I moved out of Buffy's house. Alex was always nice to me. He kept trying to ask me out, but I got through to him eventually." Willow smiled. "Before we got to really know one another, I think it bugged him that I'm gay. Not the fact I like women, he understands that. What he was never able to grasp is that I didn't like him. He's not used to being turned down."
Tara stopped Willow. "I've been meaning to ask. Why did you move out of Buffy's?"
"Long story short. You know what happened with me and Amy and Rack, right? The magic, the car wreck? Well, I pretty much gave up on magic after that. I stopped casting. But the power was always there inside of me, waiting to come out. Then Buffy got shot...by Warren. Dawn told you about that?"
"In an e-mail, yes. She said he came into the back yard while she and Xander were talking."
"Right. Buffy almost died that day. I was there, in the house, and I saw Warren. But I wasn't able to stop him. He got away before I could even get downstairs. I lost it. Control. The power just exploded out of me. I seared off an entire layer of paint from every house in the neighborhood."
Tara blinked. "Whoa."
"Whoa is right. I thought I was going to die myself. It hurt so much. But just as quickly as it had come, I felt the power drain out of me. To this day I don't know what happened. Xander and I managed to get Buffy to the hospital in time to save her life, thank the Goddess."
"But what does any of this have to do with your moving out of the house?"
"I was just getting to that. Xander told Buffy what I had done while she was recuperating. She asked me to leave the house, because I was too much of a threat to Dawn." Willow sighed. "And I did it because, well, she was right, and I knew it. My control was always fleeting at best. I was a threat to everyone around me. That's when I checked myself into the Psychiatrict Hospital. They helped me fight the cravings."
"They know about magic there?"
Willow nodded. "Not everyone on staff, but some. That's another reason I love working there." She motioned to a dark-haired woman standing beside a pillar. "Come on. My table's upstairs." Tara followed her up the stairs, to a table that was off to one side, away from the others and overlooking the dance floor. The dark-haired woman was right behind them. "Hey Becky. I didn't know you were here tonight."
"Julie called in sick. So what can I get you ladies?"
Tara realized the woman was a waitress. "Umm...just some ginger ale, thanks."
"I'll have the usual," said Willow.
Becky smiled. "Be right back." She turned and walked away, and Tara couldn't help noticing the way Willow was staring at her rear end the whole time.
"Another...friend of yours?" the blonde asked.
Willow again felt her cheeks flushing. "Something like that."
*****
Edited by: Garner at: 11/27/02 4:27:22 pm