Okay, so I know I promised I would reply to feedback much sooner. Bad Jessie…bad. I’ve been very busy with work, interviews, getting sick and entertaining all manner of guests for the past month, but I have kept this fic and all your wonderful feedback in a special place in my heart.
So as promised, replies…
Chapter 1 Feedback!
GayNow – Thanks. Actually my last few tries with the other fic have been more like hit and runs they were so bad. Oh well…
tarawhipped – Ah, someone took the bait. Glad you liked.
I love the set up here, and you managed to pack in a lot of background info in a very concise manner.
I wanted to introduce the characters and establish some relationships as quickly as possible without going into too much dialogue. I actually wasn’t sure if it was too much at once, but the positive feedback from you and others means I was worrying too much!
The idea of Faith and Xander as half siblings struck me as really funny, and highly original.
Yeah, I was particularly tickled by that idea, though I had to stop and think for a minute cuz, you know, there was that whole Faith-used-Xander-for-sex thing on the show.
I wish someone would give me a condo for a gift, wouldn’t that be the best ever?
The Rose24 – Glad you like, and yes I am still trying to work on Hit/Miss aka Run-Ins, but there’s a pretty good chance this fic will be updated first.
Guppy – Thanks, Canon Willow was always very protective of her friends, which was something I wanted to keep. And honestly, my heart ached just writing Tara’s story, but it had to be done.
SallyMcFine – Thanks, I’ve seen other fics where they were all roommates and I liked the idea and decided to see what I could do with it. As is revealed in chapter 2 yes the condo is a one-bedroom and no neither Buffy nor Tara are moving in with her.
Very touching scene with Willow accepting Tara and holding her and then Tara opening up enough to tell her about her past. That was some of the best-written exposition that I've read. You filled in the background nicely, concisely, but with enough detail that I didn't feel cheated.
I’m glad you think so. Usually when I’m thinking of a fic and where I want it to go, I tend to imagine the dialogue more than anything else, but I couldn’t get the picture of that last bit out of my head and wanted to get to it as quickly as possible without “cheating.”
Graceland – Thanks. Good pick up here:
There's a sure sense of longing from both girls but neither seems completely lovesick or on the verge of a drinking bender. It's just a question of how things will change
When I started this story I was undecided on how quickly I wanted things to progress, so I kinda left myself an opening.
As far as “the college years” are concerned, I think we actually will be going back to it more in order to answer the question of how things will change. But I do try not to put anything unnecessary.
Watson – Lovely, I don’t think that word is really used as much as it should be in general, so double thanks.
kaia – I’m glad you liked the interaction and thought it felt real. Some of it is particular memories that stick out in my mind, that I’ve adapted a bit to fit Willow and Tara. I’m not sure what all is happening with that other story, I think it’s run away from me. And you’re welcome.
AlysonGoddess – I know, it’s a little bit sad, I was a little bit sad when I started writing it too. It’ll be a little be happy in a little while.
tarebare – thanks. Yes, of course there will be W/T goodness to come, but I think more tippy-toeing will be in order first. I like that ending too. Keep watching .
Bug23 – thanks!
RageMore7 – Yes, there will be more.
WillowPowered – thanks!
Chapter 2 Feedback!
kaia – Glad you love it and that you think they’re interesting. “Me” will update soon, promise!
Watson – I’m so glad you and everyone like the interaction. I sometimes find myself reading fics where the interactions feel forced or garish, and I’m trying very hard to stay away from that. So far it seems like I’m doing good.
Still wondering how exactly things stand between Willow and Tara.
Aren’t we all? Hehehe…
And
In the flashback we have a the little sign.
Do you believe in signs? Do I? Hmm….
Miss Kittys Ball O Yarn – Thanks, I don’t think you’ll be waiting too long. And as far as your feedback being elaborate/not elaborate, it’s all good. I appreciate any and all fb as it comes (except of course if someone were to be totally inappropriate and rude, but I haven’t got any of those, so I appreciate that too.) I haven’t forgotten Run-ins aka Hit/Miss either, just backburnered it for now to let the ideas stew.
AntigoneUnbound – OMG, Mary can I just say that I love your work? Because I do, so I’m saying it, I love it all! I’m just very very bad at leaving feedback because usually by the time I’m done reading I’m speechless.
That being said, thank you. Poignant, I like that word too, you’ve captured what I was hoping I had captured, if that makes any sense.
You also write well insofar as mechanics are concerned, and that makes it even better.
Thanks, I’m glad for that. I have about 16 years worth of English teachers who would kill me otherwise. Okay, not really, except maybe for this one teacher in 9th grade…but that’s another story.
Selena Taiki – Thanks, I’ll put your two cents in the happy can, because I’m happy you like it.
feelin_way_too_groovy – Thanks, I will continue soon.
eirnlove – Thanks. I’ve seen fics where they started as friends, but much to my dismay, several of the ones I really really really like aren’t finished. Very disappointing, so why not start my own right? Guess that means I have to finish it too.
krokador – Thanks. It’s okay to be hooked. I’m hooked on several myself. (Hmm, maybe that’s why I’m all achy a lot.) Smiles and warmth are good.
it's like... I'm watching a show!
I hadn’t really planned it that way…Interesting.
WillowPowered – Thanks. They’ll get there soon enough.
Whew. I think that’s it! As far as the update is concerned, hopefully I’ll have it posted in the next few days. Work is bad, BUT I just have to do some tweaking to Chapter 3 AND I’ve already started the framework of Chapter 4. Thanks again for reading and leaving feedback!
ek