Skip to content


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

DO NOT POST - Backup in Progress

Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby xita » Mon Feb 26, 2001 5:32 am

posted 02-26-2001 07:32 EST (US)
Here's the place for people who have seen the episode to post their opinions. Opened early for Warduke and any other lucky dog who is Canadian or saw the wildfeed.


I

Need

to

have

a

little

Spoiler

Space.

And as a special treat for you, here's a wallpaper posted at the cross and stake.

sigh

THEY KISSED!

------------------
Tara: Shh.
Willow: Tara...
Tara: Shh. Darling...

xita
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby Warduke » Mon Feb 26, 2001 3:21 pm

posted 02-26-2001 17:21 EST (US)
I just saw it and this is a very powerful episode, something that I read in the wildfeed, that I thought wouldn’t be big a deal is the lack of a soundtrack…I was wrong, the lack of any music is very dramatic.

The scenes with Buffy finding her mom, the paramedics telling her that she’s dead and Buffy telling Dawn that Joyce is gone are all powerful scenes but for me the most powerful was Willow’s reaction, I just can’t stand to see Willow (or Tara) cry and it just breaks your heart to see her in so much pain, Tara was amazing, she was great with Willow, the kiss was so sweet (very nice! ) and her scene with Buffy was great.

Anya was also great in this ep; the fact that she didn’t know how to act was just, well it was just so Anya

Ok, for those who were wondering how the x-mas flashback conversation went…

Xander – How you doing there Will?…are you in the vomit club too?
Willow – I had too much nog
Tara – Oh baby, want me to rub your tummy?…she likes it when I, oh, stop explaining things

Very sweet scene, Anya also tells an “interesting” Santa story

Also, the scene with Willow running into her dorm room…it was after they all left to go see Buffy, Willow ran back in the room to get her jacket…amazing how some things can seem so different in the trailer...remember the trailer for Family?

Warduke
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby april » Mon Feb 26, 2001 3:44 pm

posted 02-26-2001 17:44 EST (US)
i know i'm not supposed to post here yet, since i haven't seen the ep, but...

joss must really really love w/t to give tara lines like the tummy rubbing one. lines, i might add, that he doesn't cut out of his eps the way that they get cut out of other writers'.

oh sigh. 23 hours, 15 minutes. why isn't it tuesday yet???

april
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby tvsurfer » Mon Feb 26, 2001 3:50 pm

posted 02-26-2001 17:50 EST (US)

Willow likes Tara to rub her tummy, oh this is just so darn precious!!!!!

thank you Warduke !!!!!!!!!!!

I take it Willow gave Tara a "look" to make her change and end that commentary on tummy rubs?

oh and is it one kiss or are there multiple kisses ?

and if its not too much to ask, how does the dialogue fit with the kiss?

tvsurfer
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby Warduke » Mon Feb 26, 2001 5:26 pm

posted 02-26-2001 19:26 EST (US)
Tvsurfer, that’s exactly what happened, Willow gave her a “that’s just between you and me” look, it was cute and as for the kiss, it was actually three kisses…WOO HOO
The dialog for the kiss was perfect, Willow tells Tara…”Tara, I can’t do this”, then Tara kisses her and says “we can do this”…like I sais…perfect.

I just watched it again and there’s something major that I missed the first time…just before they all get ready to leave to go see Buffy, Willow and Tara stare at each other, they hold hands and then they leave, while still holding hands, now that’s not what I missed, what I missed was when Willow and Tara are staring at each other, take a look at Willow’s lips, you don’t hear anything but you’ll see her lips moving and what she says is…I LOVE YOU…OMG, I can’t believe I missed it the first time, another reason to tape every ep, so you can dissect every W/T moment

Also, when Tara goes to Willow, just before they kiss, the way Willow says Tara’s name, you’ll have to hear it for yourself, it’s so heartbreaking and when Willow mentions Dawn and then she starts to cry and the way she says “little Dawn”, it’s just like when she said Tara’s name, I was teary eyed every time I watched it…which is like a 100 times now…I have to go, I need a tissue

[This message has been edited by Warduke (edited February 26, 2001).]

Warduke
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby xita » Mon Feb 26, 2001 5:51 pm

posted 02-26-2001 19:51 EST (US)
Oh god, thanks warduke, WOW, I can't wait. Damn this is too much waiting!
xita
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby wiccie » Mon Feb 26, 2001 5:57 pm

posted 02-26-2001 19:57 EST (US)
Ugh, I can't even wait 24 hrs.!

Warduke, pleeeease - is it 3 kisses including the forehead, or forehead kiss and 3 on the lips?

Thankyouthankyouthankyou!

wiccie
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby Zahir » Mon Feb 26, 2001 6:02 pm

posted 02-26-2001 20:02 EST (US)
This is from Ain't It Cool News:


WHAT’S IT CALLED?

“The Body.”

WHO’S RESPONSIBLE?

It was written and directed by series mastermind Joss Whedon. Whedon’s last episode was November’s Tara-centric “Family” (the rerun of which airs next week).

WHAT DOES TV GUIDE SAY?

“After months of fighting and ostensibly overcoming a brain tumor, Joyce (Kristine Sutherland) dies unexpectedly and in a manner seldom seen on Buffywhose overwhelming denial makes fighting the boundless forces of evil look like child's play.”

THE BIG NEWS?

Wah! Hercules “The Strong” weeps like a little girl throughout the final half-hour! He’s watched the episode three times, and it happens every time! Alyson Hannigan makes him lose it, and he can’t get it back until the credits roll!

WELL, HOW DOES THAT WORK?

Hannigan convinces us that Willow is hurting, and we love Willow, and we start hurting too! I defy any true fan of this show to get through “The Body” without Kleenex. It’s as reliable a trigger for tears as the ending of “It’s A Wonderful Life.”

SO IT’S SAD?

The cast gets a whole different kind of workout this week, and I’d put their performances against anything nominated for an Oscar this year. If this episode doesn’t garner a boatload of Emmy nominations, I’m going to start my own ****ing television academy! God bless Joss Whedon and God bless the United States of America!

IT’S NOT FUNNY?

No, it’s funny too. There’s some hilarious “Godfather II”-evoking material early in the first act (particularly some geniusy Willow lines about Santa) designed to make us yearn for everything the Scoobs have lost. But mostly the episode is sad.

WHAT ISN’T TV GUIDE TELLING US?

“The Body” is a DIFFERENT kind of “Buffy.” It’s REALLY different. Even more different than recent Whedon-directed episodes like “Hush” and “Restless.”

WHY DO YOU KEEP SAYING “DIFFERENT?”

Most “Buffy” episodes are fast-paced, utilitarian and very much a product of their medium, every moment crammed with plot, suspense, pathos, or comedy. “The Body” feels at times like something Jim Jarmusch or David Lynch might make. It’s dream-like, comprised of indelible moments: Buffy adjusting her mother’s skirt, Dawn’s friend flashing a message, Anya’s lost look as she stares out a passenger window.

WHAT’S OUR FIRST CLUE THAT THIS ONE IS GOING TO BE DIFFERENT?

No clip package. The episode begins by reprising the final shots of the prior episode.

HOW ELSE DOES IT DIFFER?

Aside from Nerf Herder’s title theme, there’s no music. (I think; it’s hard to concentrate when sobbing consumes you.) And though it’s certainly among the most cinematic episodes of “Buffy” ever made, “The Body” also feels like a stageplay at times. The episode is comprised of only four scenes, one for each act.

WHERE DO THESE FOUR SCENES TAKE PLACE?

a) Buffy’s house,

b) Dawn’s school,

c) Willow’s dorm, and

d) Sunnydale Memorial Hospital.

HOW DID JOYCE DIE?

“Looks like an aneurism,” says the doctor in the final act. “Sudden hemmoraging from a ruptured arterial vessel near where the tumor was removed.”

DO WE MEET THE GUY WHO SENT JOYCE THE FLOWERS?

No.

ANY SIGN OF ANGEL?

No.

ANY SIGN OF RILEY?

No.

ANY SIGN OF BEN/GLORY, DRU, HARMONY, DREG, JINX, THE KNIGHTS, WARREN OR SPIKE’S FEMBOT?

No, no, no, no, no, no, no and no. Even Spike sits this one out.

COME ON, HERC, GIVE US ONE BIG JUICY SPOILER!

Okay, but this one’s so big and cool, I’m going to say it backwards, like Zantanna!

!ssik neercsno tsrif rieht erahs wolliW dna araT

HERC’S RATING FOR “BUFFY THE VAMPIRE SLAYER” 5.16? ****

The Hercules T. Strong Rating System:

**** better than most motion pictures

*** actually worth your valuable time

** as horrible as most stuff on TV

* makes you quietly pray for bulletins

------------------
"O let my name be in the Book of Love.
If it be there, I care not of
That other book Above...
Strike it out! Or write it in anew.
But let it be in the Book of Love!"
--Omar Kyam

Zahir
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby Catwoman » Mon Feb 26, 2001 6:05 pm

posted 02-26-2001 20:05 EST (US)
Okay so theres going to be a kiss and an "i love you"!!! Could this episode *get* any better!
Catwoman
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby Warduke » Mon Feb 26, 2001 6:06 pm

posted 02-26-2001 20:06 EST (US)
wiccie, it's one kiss on the forehead and three on the lips
Warduke
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby Rane » Mon Feb 26, 2001 6:11 pm

posted 02-26-2001 20:11 EST (US)
four kisses *and* an 'i love you'? you wont be hearing anymore crying from this lil kitten about the lack of W/T onscreen love. no siree, joss. you've outdone yourself. again...

Oh, for it to be 8pm tuesday night...

edited to switch the number of kisses...

[This message has been edited by Rane (edited February 26, 2001).]

Rane
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby wiccie » Mon Feb 26, 2001 6:14 pm

posted 02-26-2001 20:14 EST (US)
OMJOMJOMJ - thanks Warduke! Joss Bless Canada and wildfeeds!

I have to go faint now....Blood rushing out of brain for other places...Buh bye.

*ker-thunk!*

wiccie
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby april » Mon Feb 26, 2001 6:31 pm

posted 02-26-2001 20:31 EST (US)
oh my dear lord. oh....wow. we get all this...*plus* willow mouthing "i love you?" i swear, joss must lurk on this board. joss *has* to lurk on this board. aren't these like, *all* the things we ever said we wished we could see (minus the naughty ones that just won't happen on screen), all packed into one ep?

i can't deal. i just can't. tomorrow can NOT come fast enough. i will treasure this ep forever...

april
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby Catwoman » Mon Feb 26, 2001 6:38 pm

posted 02-26-2001 20:38 EST (US)
Okay, i admit it, I'm Joss!!! hehe i wish, guy's a genius.

The thing i was wondering was that now that we've got the W/T kiss, will the 'kitten, the witches and the bad wardrobe' sign at the top of the page be changed to show the pic of W/T kissage? That'd be cool, not that i don't love the pics that are there already

Catwoman
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby tvsurfer » Mon Feb 26, 2001 6:42 pm

posted 02-26-2001 20:42 EST (US)

Thanks Warduke!!!!!!

I can go to bed happy now!!!1

4 kisses, an I love you and a scene that solidifies there relationship as a couple "we will do this together" and they leave hand in hand 'together' WOW !!!

I'll have to tape this eppie on both VCR's so if I wear out one tape I'll have another copy

tvsurfer
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby Dr.G » Mon Feb 26, 2001 6:45 pm

posted 02-26-2001 20:45 EST (US)
LOL Wiccie, heh heh. I know how you feel.
Warduke man, you have made me very, very happy.
I did not think it was possible, but you've made me even happier than I have been since yesterday!

------------------
Garfield, who wants to be an Amazon too now...

Dr.G
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby Dave V » Mon Feb 26, 2001 7:15 pm

posted 02-26-2001 21:15 EST (US)
Warduke, thanks. I just got off work (11:00 p.m. CST) and surfed immediately to this page. You've made the trip home both a little easier (ahh, romance!) and harder (will tomorrow never come?).

Zahir, thanks for the post. It's great to see the people at Ain't it Cool News being so very supportive of BtVS in general, and Willow/Tara in particular. No one can cause tears like Ms. Hannigan.

Dave V
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby xita » Mon Feb 26, 2001 7:35 pm

posted 02-26-2001 21:35 EST (US)
Ok, I play with images, but I am really no good. I will take submtions for banners. The kiss must be included as well as the name. Of course try to sneak MKF in there as well. I will change the picture at the bottom to reflect the kiss tomorrow night. xita@yahoo.com

[This message has been edited by xita (edited February 26, 2001).]

xita
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby hypergirl » Tue Feb 27, 2001 2:15 am

posted 02-27-2001 04:15 EST (US)
8 hours an 47 minutes.....how will I ever deal? LoL And oh geezness....I must go to school in about 12 minues ....must....make it ....through ....day...
hypergirl
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby Ange » Tue Feb 27, 2001 10:36 am

posted 02-27-2001 12:36 EST (US)
Very good. I think that Joss gives us all that we wanted the kiss and the i love you. The i love you was very sweet. You saw it. I have only one thing to say.

THANK YOU MR WHEDON!!!!!!

------------------

Sorry for my faults. I'm French.

-------------------------

Willow: "Hello, gay now!"

Ange
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby april » Tue Feb 27, 2001 10:40 am

posted 02-27-2001 12:40 EST (US)
ange:

who on buffy unlimited has the new ep already? you can email me the info at cyber_apple@hotmail.com if you don't want to post it.

april
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby Isolde » Tue Feb 27, 2001 4:14 pm

posted 02-27-2001 18:14 EST (US)
Wow.

Wow.

This is one of the best Buffy eps I've ever seen. Maybe the best. No music, and a lot more focus on the acting of the individuals. I've never lost anyone close to me, but SMG's reaction was very believable. Really liked the camera angles, etc, because it really made her utter loss and confusion more understandable.

Okay, let's not forget the obvious - THEY KISSED!!!!! And it was good - pretty much everything it could and should have been. And I fell in love with Tara all over again when she said "We can get through this." ... great line delivery! Woohoo! I am so happy right now!

The lack of music really made the episode work, again. Plus, there were a lot of subtleties going on between the characters, just little moments that Joss put a lot of attention into (Willow and Xander in the dorm room, for one). Plus, Anya wanting so much to understand, and her frustration about having no idea how to react. And personally, a vampire waking up in the middle of the morgue, in dead silence, right behind Dawn was eerier than all of the buildup music they have used before.

Sigh. Way to finish up the sweeps. Hope the fanfic can keep me going until the new eps!

Isolde
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby hypergirl » Tue Feb 27, 2001 4:16 pm

posted 02-27-2001 18:16 EST (US)
After we had our little kissing scene...right before it cuts to Anya and Xander discussing what they should do.....Tara is going towards Willow.....looks like she's about to kiss her again...eh just a random thought.....and whoever said it was really odd without the music was surely right....it was most def irky ...my room was all quiet and my cat was flexing her claws on my bed to where I could here it so it got really annoying LoL Anywayz ....be strong like an amazon -


Ciao -
ºAshleyº

hypergirl
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby tvsurfer » Tue Feb 27, 2001 4:21 pm

posted 02-27-2001 18:21 EST (US)

WOW!!!!!!!

amazingly well done !!!!!!

David B of the NY Post was right
this deserves the EMMY

and the women, all the women in this ep, were just amazing!!!!!

AH just nailed this, and AB was fantastic
you could feel tara's empathy as she hurt for for her lover and friends as they struggled with the loss, just as you could read the pain of her reliving her own moms death in her eyes, very well done

JW is a very luck man to have so much talent to work with and bring his stories to life.

This eppie and these performances deserve the EMMY. nothing else on the small screen compares.

tvsurfer
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby hypergirl » Tue Feb 27, 2001 4:27 pm

posted 02-27-2001 18:27 EST (US)
Oh yay for me ....I'm now a floating rose...LoL yea ...I'm hushing now
hypergirl
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby TashaR » Tue Feb 27, 2001 5:09 pm

posted 02-27-2001 19:09 EST (US)
*cheers for Aly and Amber*

That was so sweet, I was all teary. Poor Tara...Poor Willow.."Am I a grown up?" I loved how they did this...the whole episode was wonderful.

I so need to change my sig. "Aww, Baby, do you want me to rub your tummy? She likes it when I..."

TashaR
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby Anyalvr » Tue Feb 27, 2001 5:26 pm

posted 02-27-2001 19:26 EST (US)
OMG.

Everyone was so, so excellent tonight.

Willow's almost complete breakdown was so heartwrenching. And Tara, as the emotional
center, the "strong one", did so well tonight I love Tara. Amber did so beautifully

Nicholas, Emma, Anthony, Sarah, Michelle . .
all A-rate performances. But Emma and Alyson were the ones that really got me.

I have to say that this episode was masterfully executed. When my sister died suddenly a year and a half ago, I went through so many of the same reactions - it was eerie how much Buffy recreated the reality of my own life.


------------------
"I tried to be unlovable/why couldn't you do the same?"

-(jewel)

"Spank us 'til Tuesday! We promise to be bad if you do!"
-(drusilla, angel)

Anyalvr
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby eekiboo » Tue Feb 27, 2001 6:05 pm

posted 02-27-2001 20:05 EST (US)
i saw the "i love you" that Willow whispered to Tara. thank you Warduke for posting that! the first time i re-watched it, i didn't see it but then i rewinded and played again... yes! there it was! after Willow said: "I want to be there for Buffy..." Xander says something, then Willow says I LOVE YOU to Tara and then they hold hands! what a magical moment!

and talk abt PYSCHIC dreaming... i posted on this thread http://novogate.efront.com/nocgi/Forum7 ... 394-2.html
re: my dream abt Willow and Tara kissing. i didn't know abt their kissing since i hate spoilers! i was a spoiler virgin until i saw a pic of their kiss last nite. it was *definitely* a dream come true, literally!

that was the most natural kiss i have ever seen between two people in love. it was a comfort kiss... Tara goes over to a grieving Willow to support her and comforts her, as if to say: i'm here, you're not alone.. and thus she said "we'll get through this..." i still can't believe it...

this episode definitely dealt with a lot of emotions: grief, sadness, denial, disbelief, confusion, etc. when you say "The Body," it means there is nothing in it anymore. it's empty. the soul has left. when Buffy said "she's gone" at the end of the ep, she's right. she's saying their mother's life has reached its end. notice in the beginning, when she told Giles: "they said we mustn't move 'the body'..." after that, she paused. that was her realization that her mother was truly dead and thus the outbreak.

Tara's mother died when she was 17. thank you Oh Joss for revealing more truths abt Tara's life. i always thought she was still living. i *definitely* loved it when she called Willow "darling" and "baby." and that cute little hand holding during the Christmas dinner. my heart just melted... OMG... and then the KISS happened... my heart is still beating with that image in my mind!

i've also noticed there wasn't any music in the whole ep. everybody's speechless. indeed, silence speaks a thousand words. it's just fantastic! the interplay between Buffy's flashbacks to the Christmas dinner, then her fantasy of her mom surviving the ordeal, even her thinking that the doctor is lying just to make her feel better, her telling Dawn abt their mother's demise, etc. were simply done magnificently.

i am in awe. pax.

------------------
Willow to Buffy: "we have to face it, you can't handle Tara being my girlfriend..." The Yoko Factor

eekiboo
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby eekiboo » Tue Feb 27, 2001 6:31 pm

posted 02-27-2001 20:31 EST (US)
Willow: (Willow is crying while deciding what to wear.) Why can't I just dress like a grown-up? Can't I be a grown-up? I...
Tara: Shhhh...
Willow: Tara...
Tara: Shhh.. darling...
Willow: I can't do this. (Tara kisses Willow on forehead, then triple kiss on lips.)
Tara: We can do this.
Willow: Ok. We can be there for Buffy. And Dawn. Little Dawn.
Tara: We can be strong.
Willow: Strong like an amazon?
Tara: Strong like an amazon, right.
Willow: Ok. I wish I had the blue. (referring to the blue blouse that Joyce mentioned she liked on Willow.)

eekiboo
 


Thread Subject: Discussion - S5E16 - "The Body"

Postby april » Tue Feb 27, 2001 6:57 pm

posted 02-27-2001 20:57 EST (US)
my god. this was such a powerful ep. shooting it without a musical soundtrack was a stroke of genius...everything hit home so much harder.

buffy's and dawn's initial reactions were very painful to watch, but actually, two other scenes got me even more than that: first, when willow says "little dawn" and almost bursts into tears again. my god. and then when tara quietly tells buffy about losing her own mother. the way she delivered the lines, and the way they were written...i totally identified with that. it's like, someone really close to you dies, and you feel guilty about all the weird reactions you're having. and the way buffy suddenly looked at tara, like "yes, my god, you actually understand me!" just incredible.

and the scene with the scoobies...willow and tara tear me to pieces. they were just superb. aly was INCREDIBLE portraying willow's freak-out, and they had SO much empathy between them for the kiss...you could just feel the love pouring off of tara. now that i've seen it, i can't think of a better way they could have shown a kiss. you can tell unquestionably how much they love each other. and then when willow mouths "i love you" at the end...it seals the scene perfectly. and you know, even in crisis, that these two are so in love... just amazing.

this was one of the best buffy eps i've ever seen. michelle trachtenberg was incredible as always. even anya, during her breakdown scene, really moved me. (i love anya, but she's not usually the deep emotional type.) wow. wow. wow. and again, wow.

i can think no more right now. i'll say more later...

april
 

Next

Return to Board index

Return to Novogate Backup Kitten

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 8 guests


Powered by phpBB The phpBB Group © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007
Style based on a Cosa Nostra Design