quote:
Well, if she does, how can she reverse everything? ....if Anya smashes her amulet, the world returns to normal, but Anya is mortal. Is this right? Or am I completely missing something?
i would like to point out that which has been ignored rather a lot on the anyanka wish un-doing part. she doesnt have to break her amulet to undo a wish. she can just, whoosh, and undo it. Y'all remember OAFA?
crude recapeople stuck in house. people wanna leave house. people call hallie and say "what'sup with that yo. you suck." hallie says "deal. you're mistreating a child ." hallie tries to whooosh away. hallie cant cuz of her own curse. hallie undoes curse. all well and good again.RIGHT THERE. BOOM!
look at it! ME showing a BIG HUGE way vengeance wishes can be UNDONE, without ANYbody turning mortal. (unless of course the wish was mortal-a-fying someone, in which case of course that would be the undoing....) but anyway, yes, we know this, yet seem stuck on the anya sacrifice possibility. it just strikes me as being incredibly idiotic of anya, if shes all caring about xander and wanting to save him by ungranting a wish, that she'd doom herself, rather than just pull a hallie-whoose and undo the freakin wish the boring way.
anybody thoughts?
------------------
It's horrible! That's me as a vampire. I'm so evil and... skanky. And I think I'm kinda gay.
[This message has been edited by theatremouse because apparently the word "ME" is too hard for me to spell... oy.(edited March 24, 2002).]
[This message has been edited by theatremouse (edited March 24, 2002).]
IP: Logged
maudmac Doll's Eye Crystal
Posts: 78 Registered: Jan 2002 | posted March 24, 2002 04:42 *misses Tito*(Now, before anyone who doesn't remember Tito starts, he's Xander's plumber friend. I just miss him. That's all.) *sighs wistfully* Those were the days.
IP: Logged |
Ari Cool Monster Fighter
Posts: 169 Registered: Jan 2002 | posted March 24, 2002 04:46 There's a difference in ending a curse and reversing it. In OAFA, Halfrek ended the curse and they all could leave. But it didn't undo anything that had happened as a result of the wish. RedShirt boy was still hurt, everyone still knew about Dawn's stealing, and etc.Reversing a wish means going back to the moment it was granted and changing the timeline as if it never happened at all. And we've only ever seen that happen with the smashing of Anya's original pendant in The Wish. Nothing else (on Buffy, anyway) has ever been shown to actually affect time itself. All the spells and gadgets just altered certain people's perception of time. Ari
IP: Logged |
JustSomeGuy Doll's Eye Crystal
Posts: 72 Registered: May 2001 | posted March 24, 2002 05:03 Ok, I do'nt know if this should go here or not; as usual, if the mods want to move it or delete it, I'm cool..So yesterday I had this neato dream (I work nights, sleep days, etc.); I was kinda almost awake, but not quite; aware of the physical world but not a part of it yet. My best dreams come to me while I'm in this state. Anyway, it was the last episode, near the beginning, and all hell was breaking loose, or about to; but just as things were getting beyond-the-pale, no-turning-back-ever grimgrimGRIM.. We hear Joss yell "CUT", somebody else yell "Break for lunch!", and the camera pulls back to reveal Joss, Marti, a camera crew, lighting, trailers, etc. But what nobody notices is how freaked/numbed out our actors look.. Buffy is all slack-jawed, Xander is going "what the hell?..", Willow is caught between confusion and rage bordering on catatonia, Anya about the same. Willow suddenly goes "OW!", and leans over and pops something out of her eye. She looks at her hand and goes, "Contacts?". Anya touches her demony face, and says, "M,makeup?". Marti then walks over and hands them all scripts and tells them theres been a slight rewrite for the next scene, and could they go over it a little during lunch? As if mezmerized, they each look at their scripts. Willow reads through the revisions, then on to finish the whole thing- then suddenly breaks out sobbing, tears welling up in her eyes, and blurts out, "She-she's alive?" Then we hear a familiar voice say, "What? Whose alive? What'd Marti do now?" Everyone's head snaps up, then the camera cuts to- Amber Benson. And that's when I fully wake up, reach over to my clock to see the time, and suddenly remember, "Oh yeah.. one of the working titles for this ep is "Real", is'nt it?" *sigh* my sweet dreams fairy must really love me.. Guy. [This message has been edited by JustSomeGuy (edited March 24, 2002).] IP: Logged |
quote:IP: LoggedmaudmacDoll's Eye Crystal
Posts: 78
Registered: Jan 2002 posted March 24, 2002 04:42
*misses Tito*(Now, before anyone who doesn't remember Tito starts, he's Xander's plumber friend. I just miss him. That's all.)
*sighs wistfully*
Those were the days.
IP: Logged
posted March 24, 2002 04:42 *misses Tito*(Now, before anyone who doesn't remember Tito starts, he's Xander's plumber friend. I just miss him. That's all.)
*sighs wistfully*
Those were the days.
IP: LoggedAriCool Monster Fighter
Posts: 169
Registered: Jan 2002 posted March 24, 2002 04:46
There's a difference in ending a curse and reversing it. In OAFA, Halfrek ended the curse and they all could leave. But it didn't undo anything that had happened as a result of the wish. RedShirt boy was still hurt, everyone still knew about Dawn's stealing, and etc.Reversing a wish means going back to the moment it was granted and changing the timeline as if it never happened at all. And we've only ever seen that happen with the smashing of Anya's original pendant in The Wish.
Nothing else (on Buffy, anyway) has ever been shown to actually affect time itself. All the spells and gadgets just altered certain people's perception of time.
Ari
IP: Logged
posted March 24, 2002 04:46 There's a difference in ending a curse and reversing it. In OAFA, Halfrek ended the curse and they all could leave. But it didn't undo anything that had happened as a result of the wish. RedShirt boy was still hurt, everyone still knew about Dawn's stealing, and etc.Reversing a wish means going back to the moment it was granted and changing the timeline as if it never happened at all. And we've only ever seen that happen with the smashing of Anya's original pendant in The Wish.
Nothing else (on Buffy, anyway) has ever been shown to actually affect time itself. All the spells and gadgets just altered certain people's perception of time.
Ari
IP: LoggedJustSomeGuyDoll's Eye Crystal
Posts: 72
Registered: May 2001 posted March 24, 2002 05:03
Ok, I do'nt know if this should go here or not; as usual, if the mods want to move it or delete it, I'm cool..So yesterday I had this neato dream (I work nights, sleep days, etc.); I was kinda almost awake, but not quite; aware of the physical world but not a part of it yet.
My best dreams come to me while I'm in this state.
Anyway, it was the last episode, near the beginning, and all hell was breaking loose, or about to; but just as things were getting beyond-the-pale, no-turning-back-ever grimgrimGRIM..
We hear Joss yell "CUT", somebody else yell "Break for lunch!", and the camera pulls back to reveal Joss, Marti, a camera crew, lighting, trailers, etc.
But what nobody notices is how freaked/numbed out our actors look..
Buffy is all slack-jawed, Xander is going "what the hell?..", Willow is caught between confusion and rage bordering on catatonia, Anya about the same.
Willow suddenly goes "OW!", and leans over and pops something out of her eye.
She looks at her hand and goes, "Contacts?".
Anya touches her demony face, and says, "M,makeup?".
Marti then walks over and hands them all scripts and tells them theres been a slight rewrite for the next scene, and could they go over it a little during lunch?
As if mezmerized, they each look at their scripts. Willow reads through the revisions, then on to finish the whole thing- then suddenly breaks out sobbing, tears welling up in her eyes, and blurts out, "She-she's alive?" Then we hear a familiar voice say, "What? Whose alive? What'd Marti do now?"
Everyone's head snaps up, then the camera cuts to-
Amber Benson.
And that's when I fully wake up, reach over to my clock to see the time, and suddenly remember, "Oh yeah.. one of the working titles for this ep is "Real", is'nt it?"
*sigh* my sweet dreams fairy must really love me..
Guy.
[This message has been edited by JustSomeGuy (edited March 24, 2002).]
IP: Logged
posted March 24, 2002 05:03 Ok, I do'nt know if this should go here or not; as usual, if the mods want to move it or delete it, I'm cool..So yesterday I had this neato dream (I work nights, sleep days, etc.); I was kinda almost awake, but not quite; aware of the physical world but not a part of it yet.
My best dreams come to me while I'm in this state.
Anyway, it was the last episode, near the beginning, and all hell was breaking loose, or about to; but just as things were getting beyond-the-pale, no-turning-back-ever grimgrimGRIM..
We hear Joss yell "CUT", somebody else yell "Break for lunch!", and the camera pulls back to reveal Joss, Marti, a camera crew, lighting, trailers, etc.
But what nobody notices is how freaked/numbed out our actors look..
Buffy is all slack-jawed, Xander is going "what the hell?..", Willow is caught between confusion and rage bordering on catatonia, Anya about the same.
Willow suddenly goes "OW!", and leans over and pops something out of her eye.
She looks at her hand and goes, "Contacts?".
Anya touches her demony face, and says, "M,makeup?".
Marti then walks over and hands them all scripts and tells them theres been a slight rewrite for the next scene, and could they go over it a little during lunch?
As if mezmerized, they each look at their scripts. Willow reads through the revisions, then on to finish the whole thing- then suddenly breaks out sobbing, tears welling up in her eyes, and blurts out, "She-she's alive?" Then we hear a familiar voice say, "What? Whose alive? What'd Marti do now?"
Everyone's head snaps up, then the camera cuts to-
Amber Benson.
And that's when I fully wake up, reach over to my clock to see the time, and suddenly remember, "Oh yeah.. one of the working titles for this ep is "Real", is'nt it?"
*sigh* my sweet dreams fairy must really love me..
Guy.
[This message has been edited by JustSomeGuy (edited March 24, 2002).]