quote:
Originally posted by Warduke:
...I don't think that what Tara says is out of character at the end of 18, she still loves Willow with all her heart and being this close to her, spending all this time with her and seeing that Willow has changed and is working at staying away from magic, makes perfect sense to me that Tara would want to be with Willow at this point, that she couldn't stand to not be with her any longer.
quote:
Originally posted by Kendahl897:
I agree with Warduke on this one. She still loves Willow very much and Willow has come a LONG way in battling her addiction. Granted there are still issues of trust and such they need to work through, but those are issues that they have to be together to be able to work through.
Bingo on both posts.
But I have to say, I was just watching Smashed, and the idea of Amy trying to pass herself off as Tara just popped into my head, too, for some reason. I think I just got a weird, uneasy, sick sort of feeling watching her play on Willow's insecurities in order to get her to do what Amy wanted her to. (Go out and party when Willow didn't seem all that interested at first...)
Now I don't think she could pass herself off convincingly as Tara for any length of time, mainly because she doesn't really know Tara at all. Met her for all of about 2 minutes in the kitchen at the beginning of Wrecked, but that's about it. Willow would be clued in pretty darned quickly that something was "off" with Tara if Amy were to try this tactic in any sort of intensely personal or intimate scenario...and most especially during the act of lovemaking. No way could Amy pull off impersonating Tara in that department, I'd wager. Also, I don't think the writers would have made such a point of including that line in the script for Ep 18 if that weren't indeed the real Tara: "They kiss passionately, they interlock fingers, holding on as tight as they can, not letting go they keep kissing, it is intense, it is passionate, and it is above all else, love, truly and forever." It sure the hell would not be if that were Amy.
Nope. It's definitely Tara then and all the way through the "steamy sex" that ensues. But afterwards? During the time that Willow leaves Tara alone and before she returns to find her body? Just how much time does elapse there? Amy is nothing if not sneaky and resourceful...and who's to say she's not just biding her time, waiting for the perfect opportunity to step in...right after the lovemaking when Willow's defenses would be down and she's at her most vulnerable. (Not to mention Tara being at her most vulnerable...) Hey, Willow's suddenly got Tara back, she's feeling "top of the world" and what could possibly go wrong now? A perfect opportunity for Amy to step in and "take over" for just long enough to set in motion whatever plan she might have concocted...using Tara, of course, because why would Willow question anything "Tara" might ask of her....or how would it affect Willow if "Tara" were to suddenly change her mind, or turn against her via a provoked argument, and end up leaving her again...or something like that...(hard to imagine what exactly goes on inside of Amy's head now that it's spent so much time as a rat...) It would probably have something to do, though, with making sure Willow feels abandoned by "Tara" again and is broken down enough emotionally and mentally that she would presumably return to her Dark Magicks addiction and be Amy's playmate again.
Maybe it seems like a bit of a reach, mainly because we really don't have much more to work with here than the fact that Willow finds Tara's body and Willow goes Dark...but it's not beyond the realm of possibility...and it provides plenty of food for thought once we get a chance to weigh it against any new information that might be forthcoming...and it sure does fit in with the old switcheroo theory of getting us to obsess about what's going on in the one hand while Joss is yanking us around with the other...
quote:
Originally posted by Morphine:
It's not that it's stupid, but it doesn't fit what we know comes after. If Tara wasn't truly dead, and with Willow and her so close to getting back together, I think she'd have time to contact her before Willow goes Harry Potter Meets Charles Manson...
Actually, Tara probably wouldn't be able to contact anybody. You'd have to think that Amy would have had some idea for stashing her away at least until her plan had a chance to take hold...until she was sure that Tara and Willow were over and done for good.
Interesting, indeed....
quote:quote:quote: