Skip to content


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

DO NOT POST - BACKUP IN PROGRESS

Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby xita » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:13 am

I have seen a few, and I know there will be more and I thought I would make a thread about it.

This one is from Entertainment Weekly, I found it at simplysmg.com

Here we go, kids.

CONTAINS VAGUE SPOILERS!!!!

Vamping it Up - on the set, Buffy finds a song in its heart with a show-stopping musical episode.

by Mary Kaye Schilling

A funny thing happened on the way to this week's episode of Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Although TV's cult hit has always been a genre-busting anomaly-combining elements of horror, gothic romance, soap opera, satire, and slapstick - you could be fairly certain the characters wouldn't break into song.

But now Buffy's going Broadway, and it's all Stephen Sondheim's doing, really. The legendary lyricist-composer (West Side Story, A Little Night Music) is a god to Buffy creator Joss Whedon. "I know the words to every one of his songs," admits the self-described musical geek. "Well, except Passion, which I've excised from my brain. It was just wrong."

Whedon has been dreaming of staging an all-singing, all-dancing Buffy since the show's 1997 pilot. "Every season I would ask, Are we going to do the musical episode?" says Anthony Stewart Head (Buffy's Watcher, Giles), who displayed tasty vocal chops in a 2000 sequence. "Joss would say he wasn't ready. It had to be organic." Whedon's hesitation was twofold: He wanted the episode to be "a normal hour of Buffy" that forwarded existing plot points, not an out-of-sequence stand-alone. Plus, he needed to find the time to write the words and music himself-a virtually impossible task until this season, when he handed off day-to-day-show-running to exec producer Marti Noxon.

As it was, the musical homage (airing Nov. 6) took a grueling six months to make: three months banging out the score on a piano Whedon learned to play just a few years ago (despite possessing only a tenuous grip on music composition, he had no collaborators) and three months of voice and dance lessons for the actors, not to mention all the lip-synching, choreographing, shooting and editing. "It was a nightmare," says an exhausted Whedon. "The happiest nightmare I ever had."

The show's star shares his beleaguered joy. "I'm not a singer, and I hated every moment of it," says Sarah Michelle Gellar. "It took something like 19 hours of singing and 17 hours of dancing in between shooting four other episodes." Gellar's initial impulse was to use a voice double, but she nixed that after hearing her songs. "I basically started to cry and said,'You mean someone else is going to do my big emotional turning point for the season?'"

And boy, are there turning points. As Whedon points out, "songs in musicals allow characters to sing what they can't say. And in the case of our characters, the things they really shouldn't say." The catalyst for all the soul-baring is a demon named Sweet, "who thrives on chaos---and good musical numbers," says Whedon. "He puts a spell on Sunnydale because he knows song and dance will eventually destroy the town---that much heart opening is too much for people."

The resulting 35 minutes of music (11 full songs, plus fragments and an overture) and 13 minutes of dialogue---adding up to a longer-than-normal episode----is classic Buffy, a seamless blend of hilarity, high drama, and self-mockery. (Whedon found it too painful to cut his musical baby down to regular episode length and UPN offered to perform the surgery, but net execs liked it so much that they're letting it run almost eight minutes over for its initial airing.) "Buffy's first number, 'Going Through the Motions,' is a straight-up Disney production number---wicked Disney," says Whedon. But mostly "there are a lot of ballads, because the characters are going through emotions---and because I, you know, kind of go to a sad place when I write." Exceptions include a harder-rocking tune for platinum-haired bloodsucker Spike and an "old school" number for eternally squabbling couple Xander and Anya---a '30s-style song that, as Anya enviously points out, is "retro pastiche that's never going to be a breakaway pop hit," unlike [b:46c93612df]"Under Your Spell," the (rather racy) love song Tara croons to fellow witch Willow.[/b:46c93612df]

"Most of my stuff has a '70s influence---Neil Young, the Dead, Paul Williams' incredibly underrated Phantom of the Paradise soundtrack," says Whedon, who will release a soundtrack through his Mutant Enemy production company. "Somebody said the songs sounded like Sondheim and early Elton John. Hey, I can live with that."

------------------
Tara: Trying to turn me on?

Willow: I have to try now?

I

xita
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:14 am

"Rather racy?"

You mean we're going to need the fire hoses and water-dropping helicopters as well as the crisis centers on Tuesday night?

------------------
Remember the Kitten Board Mantra: "Joss is nuts about Tara, Willow/Tara and Amber!"

"No, it's okay. Lost is good. Willow and I always know how to find each other." - Tara to Anya, Bargaining, Part 2

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:14 am

rather racy?! did I mention how badly I want to see this ep?!

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:14 am

Thanks Xita! ^_^
"racy" ohh, now that's my kind of.. *cough* anyway, I *so* wanna see this.
But I wouldn't go for "water-dropping helicopters" I kinda have a problem with those, specially if they drop more water than needed ^^;;;; I don't wanna drown.

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:14 am

Damn it, when is February coming!?!!

In the mean while, I'll have to do with the two-minute clip...and spoilers

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:14 am

Holy crap!

Episode 07, 11 full songs, and 13 minutes of dialogue. I knew those shirt numbers from Bargaining meant something.

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:15 am

Sondheim is good, but Elton John? Eek.

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:15 am

Racy??? Hmm........

Okay...

Kittens, START YOUR ENGINES!!!

The Junky...Is It Tuesday Yet???

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:15 am

awwwwww yeeeeeeah, we get a rather racy pop hit! i love it!

at this point, i'm very willing to sacrifice my weekend to make it tuesday now.

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:15 am

Did I mention how much I'm ready to spontaneously combust now??!! *sigh* I haven't slept since Tuesday and Diana sez I'm getting decidedly cranky. IS IT TUESDAY YET?!!

------------------
"Sometimes, we just can't make it on our own. We all need someone to love us, to help remind us that there's good in the world, to keep us from going crazy."

Willow from Dacia's The Dreamer Awakes

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:15 am

quote:
Originally posted by j_uk:
Holy crap!

Episode 07, 11 full songs, and 13 minutes of dialogue. I knew those shirt numbers from Bargaining meant something.


great observation there, j_uk.. I never would have made the connection..
-Shannon

------------------
*~*~*~*~* I'm gonna be a fireman when the floods roll back. There's trees in the desert since you moved out. And I don't sleep on a bed of bones *~*~*~*~*

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:16 am

Thanks xita, oh this will be so good, that (racy ) love song will be burned into every Kitten 's brain

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:16 am

the first 2 numbers make sense, but the 13 minutes of dialogue is stretching it, especially when you consider that JOss had not even shot or edited this ep by the time they showed those numbers. Course here in LA UPN is ch. 13, maybe that's it

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:16 am

Racy love song crooned by Tara

THUD!!!

IS it Tuesday yet, is it Tuesday yet, oh God make it Tuesday already.

"Am I under your spell? Nothing I can do..."

"I'm a breast gal myself..."

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:16 am

im going to be in physical pain until tuesday, aren't i?
and then i wont even get to see it cuz i have a going away party to go to, actually i sorta of organized it but had no say in the date....grr argh
but i'll make sure to tell all my buffy watching friends that have to tape it to wait until 9:10! (just to be safe)

can't wait!

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:16 am

Here's one I just read:

Nothing too spoilery at all...nothing you wouldn't know about from a basic TV Guide ep description.

Oh, but it has conflicting numbers on the songs and dialogue.

Title: Buffy The Vampire Slayer: The Musical: Once More With Feeling
Stars: Sarah Michelle Gellar, Nicholas Brendon, Alyson Hannigan, James Marsters, Emma Caulfield, Michelle Trachtenberg
Special Guest Star: Anthony Stuart Head
Guest Stars: Hinton Battle and Amber Besson
Writer: Joss Whedon
Original Songs, Music and Lyrics By: Joss Whedon
Songs Produced By: Jesse Tobias and Christophe Beck
Score: Christophe Beck
Choreographer: Adam Shankman
Creator Joss Whedon
Director: Joss Whedon
Executive Producers: Joss Whedon, Marti Noxon, Gail Berman, Sandy Gallin, Fran Rubel Kuzui, and Kaz Kuzui
Running Time: 51 minutes without commercials
Media: UPN Television Series (NTSC VHS Screener)
Season Premiere, Tuesday, November 6, 2001,
at 8pm (ET/PT)
Network: United Paramount Network (Check your local cable/satellite listings for channel)
TV Rating: TV 14
Reviewer: Mark A. Rivera

Joss Whedon, Creator and Executive Producer of Buffy The Vampire Slayer admitted that he always wanted to make a musical. Whedons goal was to tell a story that was based in song where the big story points and emotional moments are expressed through songs. Taking a block of time to write the episode, Whedon took into consideration which cast members would be more comfortable with dancing and singing and which would not and mapped out the story to play off of each cast members strengths while giving each cast member a moment, which meant that the entire cast had to go for singing and dance lessons after hours in addition to rehearsals.

The episode entitled Once More With Feeling contains 14 original songs written by Whedon with only 8-minutes of actual dialogue and is being broadcast in a letterboxed aspect ratio of (1.85:1). The songs are specifically crafted for specific characters in groups and alone in order to build upon the character arcs and storylines in ways that dialogue alone cannot realistically achieve.

Tony Award-Winning Broadway Star Hinton Battle (The Wiz, Bob Fosses Dancin) is Sweet, a demon summoned to Sunnydale who has literally turned the world into a musical where the citizens of Sunnydale break out into song and dance during points of emotional expression uncontrollably. The problem is that since the songs are sparked by a strong inner emotions being swelled up, the Scooby Gang keep singing things they did not want to say, unloading secrets and surprises that could tear them all apart since the song and dance is involuntary. Adding fuel to the fire is that according to ones body chemistry, prolonged forced singing and dancing is leading to spontaneous combustion and could wipe out everyone if a way is not found to defeat the demon, who just may be even stronger than the slayer herself.

Whedon envisions the episode as a sort of sequel to the acclaimed episode Hush where he experiments with communicating a story without spoken language. For the most part, the episode works well because the singing and dancing is choreographed to work off of the strengths of the cast, but no matter how much one person tries to cover-up for the other, the reality is some of the actors belong on the Golden Throats CD with William Shatner and Don Johnson. However there are a few impressive performances from Sarah Michelle Gellar, who looks absolutely radiant and does a good job on her songs as well as a great job with her choreographed dance numbers, which I think benefited greatly from her training on the series over the years in the choreographed fight scenes the show is known for.

A few other cast members stand out with surprisingly great singing ability in the episode. These include Amber Benson as Tara, Emma Caulfield as Anya, and Michelle Trachtenberg as Buffys little sister, Dawn. Hinton Battle is one of the best actors to play a demon on the show in awhile and he steals every scene he appears in not only because he is a professional singer and dancer, but also because he just has a natural presence that seems perfectly suited for the screen as well as the stage. By the end of the episode, many things will show signs of big changes to come with special surprises that have been building up over the seasons too.

Overall if I were to compare Buffy The Vampire Slayer: The Musical: Once More With Feeling to the big screen adaptation of Grease and then to the silver screen sequel Grease 2, I can thankfully state that the episode is closer to Grease than Grease 2.

Buffy The Vampire Slayer: The Musical: Once More With Feeling will debut on Tuesday, November 6, 2001, at 8PM (ET/PT) with a repeat encore performance to air Friday, November 16, 2001, at 8PM (ET/PT) only on UPN.

Copyright 2001 By Mark A. Rivera
All Rights Reserved.


There you go kids,
I think the conflicts between spoken word and singing will continue simply because of the fact that some reviewers will count a single line sung as spoken word as opposed to an individual song...and I won't even go into reprises.
--Swa

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:17 am

Hey thanks, swa . . .

Too bad they spelled ASH and Amber's names wrong in that info section up top, huh?

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:17 am

quote:
Originally posted by tyche:
Sondheim is good, but Elton John? Eek.

Right there with ya, babe.

I don't care though, this is totally gonna rock. Racy love song...can't believe I just read that...gettin' all hot and bothered just thinking about it...must go build time machine to take me to next Tuesday....

And Amber has "great singing ability"! Yeah!

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:17 am

Yes, "eek" to Elton John indeed . . . I gotta hear his stuff eight times a week (well, seven, I refuse to work Tuesdays) at work and ya know, after 300-plus times, The Lion King just kinda loses its charm . . .

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:17 am

This is the exactly the sort of thing one likes to read when one wanders in from reality(ie the news) wowza! thanks xita & swa for posting the articles. oh happy happy joy joy. i pity the people around me when this comes out- i have already annoyed family/friends with btvs before the musical, now i shall have the ability to both annoy them & offend them with my bad singing of the musical numbers.
huzzah! thanks peeps! did i say i was excited - eeps, did not think of the other people who are not from here- so if i was being naughty, forgive me- am only in joy overload. & if i may say so, i am just so happy to have all yr divine kitties to help me through& put up with my babbling, since we can all ramble together.

art

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:17 am

posted by nikita at the C&S:

Entertainment Weekly Review of the Musical (Possible Spoilers!!)

My apologies if this has already been posted but I just got the current ETW mag and thought I'd share the review. I'm also new to the board so here's a big hello to everyone too!


Continuing what has been a smooth transition from the WB to UPN, Buffy high-kicks off sweeps on Nov 6 with a musical episode that features songs written by creator Joss Whedon. Although this gimmick has provided some of the more self-indulgent moments in shows like Drew Carey and The Simpsons, this time it works. Someone in Sunnydale has summoned a demon who has the entire town involuntarily performing Broadway-style numbers, and Buffy and her friends find themselves singing things they were unable to tell one another before. Buffy and Spike express their true feelings, and Tara sings to Willow about being under her spell while Willow does something that makes Tara levitate off their bed. (Hmmm...) It's easy to cut the regulars some slack, but the Tony Award-winning Broadway performer Hinton Battle surprisingly fails to make much of an impression through his demon makeup. Still when was the last time a show had you laughing out loud, humming along and promising yourself that you'll tune in next week? (Three and a half stars) She sings! She dances! She slays us!
--------------------------------


hmmmm indeed!

ches

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:18 am

"Tara sings to Willow about being under her spell while Willow does something that makes Tara levitate off their bed."

What could Willow possibly be doing?

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:18 am

Well, well...It looks like my theory (from the early script spoilers - can't even remember if it's in this thread) that Willow moves out of frame down Tara's body to do something yummy is panning out to reality.

It's not just a run-on sentence, it's my run-on brain.

I shall now swoon in rapture...*thud*

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:18 am

wiccie, len and I were commenting on that the other day. We owe you props, you saw the vision.

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:18 am

Thanks, Xita, but Joss gets all the props.

I just think one of my fillings picked up his naughty brainwaves for a few moments...Mmmmm...Naughty brainwaves of Willow and Tara...

*resume swoon*

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:18 am

quote:
Originally posted by Warduke:
"Tara sings to Willow about being under her spell while Willow does something that makes Tara levitate off their bed."

What could Willow possibly be doing?


Well . . .

It certainly can't be something that generally precedes the activity your smiley icon depicts, eh Brian?

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:19 am

Got this from the simplySMG board

'Buffy' sings!
Musical 'Slayer' is spectacular
By Scott D. Pierce
Deseret News television editor


You'll have to excuse Sarah Michelle Gellar if she's a little bit defensive about her show, "Buffy the Vampire Slayer." After all, it remains one of the best-written, best-acted programs on TV and, in many quarters, it has never gotten the respect it deserves.
Which is why Gellar has no patience with people who can't see past the admittedly offbeat title and think the show is something far different from what it really is people she described as "stupid people," rather bluntly (but sweetly).
"I don't mean to be rude, but I think that people that would say that it's just ignorance," Gellar said. "Sometimes people look at a title. I know when (executive producer) Joss Whedon was first creating the show . . . people didn't want a show named 'Buffy the Vampire Slayer' because they were afraid it would turn people off.

James Marsters and Sarah Michelle Gellar perform a duet.

"This show is the most wonderful mix of brilliant, witty writing and phenomenal performances and evolving stories. If people say they won't watch it . . . that really is just ignorance."
And if some people turn up their nose at a show called "Buffy the Vampire Slayer," what will they say about this coming Tuesday's episode (7 p.m., UPN/Ch. 24) officially, it's titled "Once More With Feeling," but, unofficially, we're calling it "Buffy: The Musical."
That's right. An hourlong episode written and directed by series creator/executive producer Joss Whedon in which the cast performs musical production numbers.
Skepticism among even fans of the show is understandable. Heck, I thought it was a terrible idea, and I love "Buffy."
And I was wrong. This episode is a triumph maybe the best ever, which is saying a lot.
"Once More With Feeling" is better than any movie musical in memory. It's better than a lot of Broadway musicals.
It's funny and shocking and heartfelt. It mocks itself without becoming a parody. And it makes sense within the "Buffy" universe that all these people would suddenly be singing and dancing. (I won't give it away, but there's a demon involved.)
And this is not a stand-alone, let's-go-out-in-the-barn-and-put-on-a-musical show. "Buffy's" ongoing story arc is advanced in big ways. HUGE ways.
All the regulars have their moments Gellar, Nicholas Brendan (Xander), Emma Caulfield (Anya), Anthony Stewart Head (Giles), Alyson Hannigan (Willow), James Marsters (Spike), Amber Benson (Tara) and Michelle Trachtenberg (Dawn). Not all are of equal vocal talent Head, Benson and Caulfield turn in the best performances, but even the non-singers are made to look good.
It's not particularly scary, but there are some big surprises including one that will have fans of the show picking their jaws up off the floor.
This is the sort of risk-taking TV that the Emmys ought to reward but won't. Whedon was absolutely right when he said, "There are some people who never take genre shows seriously. It's a prejudice . . . that I'll never understand. Because (they think) anything to do with fantasy turns them off, and anything that's humorous must not be meaningful.
"So this year (the 'Buffy' cast) are all going to be doctors," he joked.
But, no joke, Tuesday's "Buffy" is the best thing to hit TV in a long time. http://deseretnews.com/dn/view/0,1249,340007521,00.html

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:19 am

Oh boy - I just read that last review and now I'm on edge - talking about how there are HUGE plot points in the ep and something jaw-dropping is going to happen. At first I was just excited about the music, but now with the importance of the plot that goes along with it, I think I'm so anxious I might bust. And I'm glad that it's getting good reviews. Maybe this year could be Emmy year for the show - the musical might get people's attention and raise their interest in the show. And I love Sarah's defiant, almost beligerent attitude in the article! It's so cool that she's defending the show's integrity.

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:19 am

wiccie wrote: "It looks like my theory...that Willow moves out of frame down Tara's body to do something yummy is panning out to reality."

Wow. That just made my body shake and my eyes water. Seriously. Could it really be? Oh, only two more days....

And what a great review just above! "'Once More With Feeling' is better than any movie musical in memory. It's better than a lot of Broadway musicals." Wow. I am going to do my damnedest to get all the people I've been trying to convince for years to watch the show to watch this ep. I am going to do some serious Buffy proselytizing over the next few days.

And more big praise for Amber's singing! And I can't fail to notice that she's referred to as a regular...not that I think that means anything, but it's nice to see her treated as such even if it's not official.

And this: "...there are some big surprises including one that will have fans of the show picking their jaws up off the floor."

I could not possibly be any more excited for this ep.

I

Unregistered(d)
 


Reviews of Once More With Feeling Spoilerish

Postby Unregistered(d) » Wed Mar 27, 2002 2:19 am

Review from 'People', copied from the Cross & Stake General Spoilage board:
quote:
Show of the week: BTVS

Truly, death has no dominion over Buffy Summers, so a small thing like a change of networks isn't going to get the Slayer down.

Last spring Buffy (SMG) sacrificed her life to save kid sister Dawn (MT) on the WB. Last month her witch friend Willow (AH) managed to bring aobut Buffy's resurrection on UPN. Buffy didn't gush with gratitiude becuae in a smart twist--it turned out she had been resting in peace rather than sweating in a "hell dimension" as assumed by well-meaning Willow.

I never thought Buffy or I would live to see the day this series (now in iths sixth season ) entered the musical dimension, but it happens on Nov. 6th when a diabolical dancer [transcriber's note: aren't they all? ;-)] (Broadway star Hinton Battle) casts a spell that has Sunnydale's citizens singing out their secret thoughts. Creator Joss Whedon's original songs are surprisingly decent and his actors remarcably game. The result is an entertaining episode (repeating on Nov. 16th at 8p.m.) that advances story lines and further develops characters while offering a playful diversion from demon-battling routine. Though Buffy may not sing as well as she slays, surly blond vampire Spike (JM) gives Billy Idol a run for his money.
Bottom Line: Alive and Well



I

Unregistered(d)
 

Next

Return to Board index

Return to Other Backup

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 141 guests


Powered by phpBB The phpBB Group © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007
Style based on a Cosa Nostra Design