Quote:
Originally posted by Gatito in the Joan of Arcadia thread.
Last word here, from me, on "gender issues" (if you wanna hear more, please email/EZ-inbox me, or take it to . . . the Trans thread, I guess): I assume . . . no, I believe that gender is a complex social construct for everyone, whether you're gender-queer, gender dysphoric, femme, butch, or just "average male or female." I also believe it is a Good Thing when one is aware of gender as a construct. That doesn't mean that one ever need question their gender identity. However, some of us, like myself, have found it unavoidable to confront the complexity of gender consciously, and question it. Society did that to me. That said, while I regret the shame and ostracism that society inflicted on me, I don't regret that it made me into a person who questions the gender duality we're all indoctrinated into (to wit: as they say, what's the first question people ask about a new baby?).
I may be misinterpreting some of what you have said, but if so, you can always set me 'straight'.
I don't quite agree with the statement that gender is a complex social construct for everyone. Most men are born and look like baby boys, they grow up to be men, feel like men and behave in a way that is considered typically male. No problems there for them or society. Most women are born looking like baby girls and they grow up into women, feel like women and behave in a way that is considered typically female. No problems there either. Most of the time it works out fine. I think gender only becomes an issue for those who do not fit neatly into the standard package, but I think we have to make a difference between behavior and gender identity.
A woman can act in a way that may (by whatever society she is living in) be considered non typical female behavior -or rather- male behavior. This does not mean she has problems with her own gender identity, but the people around her may have problems with it. They may assume she is a lesbian, or that she wants to be a man or that every lesbian wants to be a man, even when she identifies as a woman and has no doubts about it and has made that perfectly clear. The issue here would be the way society views and translates her behavior, not the way she feels about herself.
I think the problem may be that gender isn't a complex social construct at all, at least not to most people, it's 'construction' seem very simple: if you are born looking like a baby girl, you will become a woman, act like a woman and you will love a man. If you are born looking like a baby boy you will become a man, act like a man and love a woman. That is what most of us grow up learning right? This is what we are taught in school and by our elders. The problem is that it isn't always that simple. I've said this before, sometimes a woman is a man and man is a woman or both, and vice versa, and sometimes a woman loves a woman or both, and vice versa. Sometimes a woman 'acts' like a man, but she is still a woman, and vice versa.
Because we are not told when growing up that this is the way it can be as well, we have to figure it out for ourselves, and the people around us have to do so as well and not freak out by something that is different from what is expected. That isn't an easy thing to do. An even bigger problem is that some societies or groups of people who have power actively 'teach' these things are wrong.
Society did not force me to question my gender, I did that on my own. I had to figure it out on my own, accept it, fret over it, worry about how people would react. It could have been much easier if, when growing up, I would have been told that people like me exist and that it is ok. I am not saying we should turn the whole world upside down and do away with the whole 'concept' of boy and girl when we are born, I would just really like it if when children are taught the facts of life they are also taught sometimes it can be a little different and that that is ok, if it happens to you it is ok, if it happens to your friend or family it is ok, it is no reason to be afraid or to make laws against it. Just that, nothing 'heavy', just so LGBT people do not have to figure it out on their own and have their friends and family wig out because they have never heard of it, or have been taught it is wrong. So yeah, it would be a very good thing if everyone were made aware of the possible complexity of gender and sexuality.
Until that happens, the media can play a very important part in that, in helping people understand a little more about themselves or others. Unfortunately some movie/TV show makers stick their heads in the ground and pretend what they show does not matter, and they purposely do more harm where there is enough to go around already. It doesn't have to be preachy and saintly, just a fair representation of LGBT people in books and on TV would make life for everyone a lot easier. It helped me, when I came out of my closet there was an MTF transsexual on Big Brother, think of that program what you will, but the fact that she was on it and open about herself, made it easier for me to come out to my friends, family and co-workers, because at least now they knew trans people exist. Btw, that year Big Brother was won by a lesbian, so heh, I bet she helped a few girls by being out in the open (pardon the pun) as well.
Sprhrgrl, what you are doing is very important, and it takes a lot of guts. Good luck to you.
The last mosquito that bit me had to check into the Betty Ford Clinic.
--Patsy Stone
Out
Out
Out
I'm kinda getting the feeling that the hypothesis of the social construction of gender seems threatening, but I don't see why it should be.
Out
Out
)
) But the stories of the guys are still moving and, to me, eminently relatable-to (um, that's not a legit phrase, is it?
And the guy's Centurion didn't go very well (a couple of follow-up surgeries, and not predictable ones, I gathered), so that's not too cool, either.