sam, I hope you don't mind, but I'm gonna cut and paste your XWP comments, and respond over on the Xena thread.
GG Protecting *this* thread from any more of my obsession!
_____________________
I still see dead lesbian cliches
While written SF has inspired or anticipated technologies such as Arthur C Clarke's fictional writings about geosynchronous satellites, which are an everday technology, and space elevators, which hopefully will be one day, I can't think of any new scientific or technological developments influenced by Star Trek. In fact, that's one of the primary reasons why Star Trek and almost all TV series are a poor excuse for SF--their inaccurate and unrealistic portrayal of science. To be fair, Star Trek didn't originate its bad ideas--all of Star Trek's bad science can be found in earlier SF stories, but that doesn't mean that they had to imitate the inaccurate stories--there were also plenty of accurate ones before Star Trek too. While I can't deny that Star Trek has increased American society's exposure to SF ideas and stories, I wish it had popularized better material.
"Star Trek" may be a "poor excuse for SF" (though I don't agree with your assessment) but it has done alot for science fact(see below).
Its portrayal of the future and how little changes in science and technology impacted it is another area where Star Trek fails as SF. Authors who have no basis for some of their science but who do a good job exploring the impact of such changes on society can also write good SF. I love what Lois McMaster Bujold has done with impact of biological technologies from sex selection to uterine replicators on Barrayar, especially how the impact on technology influences the role and power of each sex. Most anatomical and behavioral biological differences between human sexes arise from the fact that the cost of having a child is many millions of times greater for women than men. While contraception is a big step towards bridging that goal by separating sex and reproduction, uterine replicators (in-vitro gestation) would go much further and have correspondingly greater social impacts.
Trek's optimistic future was inspiring to many and also sickenly sweet to many.
--
"Omnia mutantur, nihil interit." -- "Everything changes, but nothing is truly lost."
Peter Griffin: Brian, there's a message in my Alpha Bits. It says "OOOOOO".
Brian Griffin: Peter, those are Cheerios.
Return to Genuine Molded Plastic
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 28 guests