The bad reviews made me curious enough to download the pilot and see it for myself. I cannot say it is the worst show I have seen this season, I reserve that honor for Medical Investigation which annoyed me beyond belief. The cliches, stereotypical characters and crappy ´been there done that´ stories of that show pissed me off too much to enjoy it´s crappiness. This pilot did not annoy me and therefore I could be amused by it´s badness.
The premise is in no way original, but most stories have already been told in one way or another, so I can´t hold that against this show. It could have been good, but I agree with ASA that it suffered from premature you know what. They could have taken the time to introduce the characters, set up the mystery, string us along, like with Lost or Desperate Housewives. How can they keep the story and any possible interest going for one season, let alone more?
Everything moved ultra fast. A woman drowns? Breath into her mouth twice and voila! She is alive and dries up like she just finished running for Ms Universe. Clearly she is the daughter of Satan, no mere mortal would pull that off. She of course immediately falls for the handsome guy and is at least subconsciously ready to commit bloody murder (of course that gasstation guy would not notice the HUGE pool of gasoline he was walking through), she is at least half blond girl after all so naturally she cannot be complete without a handsome boyfriend. The utter and complete lack of humor won´t work in it´s favor either.
The only thing that really did piss me off was that sleazy doctor. "An imperfection"? Nice bedside manner asshole. "That does not look like any birthmark I have ever seen". Yeah, GREAT way to reassure your patient nitwit. Still, for the most part I was amused by the cliched story and the one dimensional characters (can´t blame the actors for that).
I am not amused enough to keep watching and eventhough I have Medical Investigation three episodes to change my mind, I can´t do the same for this show.
Edited by: DrG at: 1/27/05 1:58 pm