
Excellent review and summary Dr G. I thought this was superbly done. The acting was excellent, I was particularly impressed with Rachel Stirling. The article tyche posted was spot on in that there is no real need for some of the narration as you can clearly see what Nan is thinking due to Rachel Stirling's reactions. Where the narration was used to condense plot it really didn't bother me that much.
I thought some of the metaphors were a little over-done. I think we all got what the oysters were a representation of without having it pointed out to us so many times. Also the fire that appears on the screen just as Nan and Kitty have their first fight that leads into the sex scene. Things are heating up! Do you get it! Thought that was a little much.
But these are really minor petty complaints. And that was honestly all I could come up with as far as things I didn't like go. My main complaint is that it didn't last long enough. As soon as it finished I wanted to see more. Which is always the sign of a good show. I agree with Twisted Rabbit that I thought the book was better. I think however that is because no one's adaptation is ever going to be as good as the way you imagined it in your head. Maybe that's just me though.
Oh, wait, I had another complaint. I didn't like that Andrew Davies had them kiss before the kiss in the coach, which is the first kiss in the book. I thought this somewhat took away from the impact of the build up work he'd done. I like the way that they kiss in the carriage because they just can't hold back anymore. I didn't like that the first kiss in the series was done as a kind of game. He had built it up so well to that point and I think that you could tell through some of Keeley Hawes expressions that she was also in love with Nan. I don't feel you needed that physical representation at that point. And I can't believe I'm complaining at all about women kissing on screen. Someone slap me.
One of my favourite moments was lifted directly from the book and lived up fully to my expectations. The moment when Kitty goes to kiss Nan's hand as she's bidding her farewell and smells the fish on her hand. Rachel Stirling's expression here was priceless.
Kitty: You smell like...
Nan: (mortified) I know, a herring!
Kitty: No, not like a herring. Like a mermaid.
I love this. Just the last line and the look on Kitty's face. And did anyone else think that Kitty's talking voice sounded a lot like Julie Andrews?
The musical numbers were excellent, particularly "I'm Rather Shy". The love scene was very good too, good job by the actors. It was your typical moments of love making cut together into a sequence. And yes, the title act is included in the love making. That was a pleasant surprise.
I can't wait until next week. That was so, so good.
Edited to add - I've read the book so could fully spoil you if you like Dr G. However, according to comments by Keeley Hawes they changed the ending slightly. So my spoilage may not be entirely accurate, but I can't imagine they'll change it that much.
"I hope that when the time comes I die like my Dad, peacefully in his sleep. Not screaming in fear like his passengers." The Son of a recently deceased American bus driver.
Edited by: walker at: 10/11/02 1:20:29 pm