Ahhh!!! I feel like screaming; shouting at the injustice of it all. It wasn't Willow at the door a little while ago- it was Buffy. And to say that her attitude wasn't all Miss Suzy Sunshine would be putting it mildly. She was furious. Not, as I assumed, at Willow, but at me.
"I just left the house." She said. "How could you?"
"I...what?"
"She's devastated Tara!" She said. "I found Willow on the sofa crying her eyes out. When I asked her what was wrong she said your name, that was all, just 'Tara'."
Hearing that she was crying over me made my heart hurt. But damn it, I did what I had to do! So I stuck my chin out at Buffy defiantly, daring her to take her next shot. I was righteous in my anger.
"I figured she was just missing you as usual," she went on, "but then she tells me that you came by." Buffy stopped and took a breath, as if trying to calm herself. She looked up at me and her eyes were filled with pain for her friend. I looked away.
After a second she continued talking in a whisper, "She told me what you said."
I looked up at her startled. What I said?
____________________________________________
“Tara honey, Will you give me another chance? Will you give us another chance?” She whispered against my lips.
"I don't know if I can." I replied.
She jumped back, as if I had shocked her. In her eyes there was fear and just a hint of despair.
"What? I don't understand. I mean, I get why, but I thought...we were just, and... Huh?"
I sighed. "Willow. It isn't that I don't love you, I do- more than anything in the world." Upon hearing those words, my Willow smiled; the face that just a second ago was filled with anxiety now was brilliant in its radiance. It physically pained me to say what was next, "But..."
"NO! No buts." She said, her voice quivering. "Stay with the loving me, loving me is good.”
"But," I said again, determined to get this out, even if it killed us both. "I just don't see how this can work."
At this she got to her feet and stared down at me on the sofa, she looked determined.
"It can work, it has worked!" she said, almost pleading to me with her words. "Look, I know I messed up, believe me I know and what I did was terrible, unforgivable even, but Tara, I love you."
Tears started forming in my eyes at those words. How long had I lived my life without them? How long had I lived without anyone to love me?
She knelt down in front of me, grasped my hands into hers. "I know that I'm being selfish, but I love you and I need you so much. I'm asking you to forgive me baby. Please, I know it isn’t fair to you, but forgive me."
I was openly crying by then-knowing that she loved me; it warmed my soul and killed my spirit at the same time.
"Oh sweetie, I do. I do forgive you. Don't ever think that. I know that it was the magick controlling you, and I know that you stopped and I'm very, very proud of you. I forgive you Willow, I do."
"Then what is it?" She pleaded, "Why can't we just work this out?"
"Because I'm afraid!" I yelled.
She took a step back, startled, "Of what?"
"Of you."
_____________________________________________
"How could you?" Buffy whispered harshly.
My face hardened and I turned my back to her. "Please Buffy, just leave this be."
She turned me around. "No, I can't just leave this be. Damn it, it's Willow. I know she's made mistakes, but that doesn't make her something to be...afraid of." She spit the last two words out as if they were venom.
"You made her feel like a monster, like she was something evil-a demon."
"Oh, Buffy..." I said, realizing. I reached out my hand to comfort her but she shrugged away at my touch.
"You're my friend, Tara. I care about you and I thought I knew you, but I never imagined that you could be this cruel." With that she took something out of her jean pocket.
"Willow didn't know I was coming here and she certainly doesn't know I'm about to give you this," she handed me an envelope, "I was with her when she started writing it, a couple of days after my birthday party-when the two of you started talking again. I don't know exactly what she wrote but I do know that it is addressed to you. Take what you will from it."
With that she opened the door to my apartment and left.
Momma, I didn't want to open the letter believe me. I was terrified of the letter. I put it on my dresser and left it there, intent on ignoring it. I went about the house doing chores and making lists, trying not to think of what Buffy had said to me and certainly not thinking about what that letter said.
Ultimately however, its pull was too much for me and I succumbed to temptation.
________________________________________
Tara,
I don't know where to start. How does one go about starting a letter to the person she loves most in the world and the person she has hurt the most as well?
I could start by saying I'm sorry, but you know that. I have to believe you know that. Baby, I've made mistakes, big awful mistakes and I let this thing control me. But even while I was being all kooky, the only real thing to me was you. When you left me, after I did that spell, I knew you were right. I didn't admit it to myself but I was glad you left. Not because you were gone, because, God, that was unbearable, but because then I couldn’t hurt you. I know I hurt you. And that kills me.
I was so scared Tara. Without you, everything was impossible. So predictably, I used that as an excuse to use more magic. And that magic was terrifying. Rack was terrifying. Knowing that I had that in me was terrifying. But it was better than facing up to everything. Better to knowing that I screwed up and that caused me to lose you.
The night of the accident with Dawn was the turning point for me. Everyone thinks that it's because I hurt Dawn and believe me that was a big reason, but it wasn't the main one.
I was in that car, tripping on magic, but I was aware. I knew the car was going too fast, I knew we were going to hit something; that we could get hurt. But I didn't care.
Part of me wanted to. I wanted to get hurt. I wanted to, I don't know; end up in a coma or something. Maybe even die.
I know this sounds terrible, God, I realize how awful it is now. But you were my everything and I had failed you and rather than face up to my mistakes, I, like a little child, wanted to use my death as a way out. Pretty stupid huh?
I was scared silly of what I had become. And it was then, after Dawn slapped me and after Buffy almost turned away from our friendship that I realized I had to grow up.
I wasn't who you feel in love with anymore. I was something spooky, something dark.
That night I cried out your name and knew I had to win you back.
Baby, everyday is a challenge, but everyday I know I can do it-for you.
I don't want to become that person again; I want to be the one you fell in love with. So, I'll try everyday, I'll win back your trust, I will. You're my everything and I love you.