Feedback replies: I am sorry to report that I do not have replies to feedback at this time. I am on vacation and going back and forth between my laptop, with a keyboard and a decent word processor, and my phone, with the internet access. I promise I will respond to your feedback as soon as I can.
Rating: NC-17
Feedback: I am genuinely interested in both positive and negative feedback on all of my writing, from emoticons to tearing the work apart. If you have something to say, please say it. If you’re concerned about posting critique publically for whatever reason, I am amenable to receiving it via PM.
Notes: The entirety of chapter 4, including ‘Experimenting,’ take place across the episodes “This Year’s Girl” and “Who Are You?”
Content disclaimer: Sex: yes. Angst: Yes. Violence: No.
I don’t own this disclaimer: The following is a work of fanfiction that takes place within the Buffyverse. The entire Buffyverse ( including setting, characters and plot) property of its owners, including but not limited to Joss Whedon and Mutant Enemy. The episode “Who Are You” was written by Joss Whedon. No copyright infringement is intended by this work. However, any material within not copyright any other party is copyright me.
Acknowledgements: Thanks to my awesome beta reader, dlline. I still can’t believe sent this to her the week before Christmas, with little warning, and she was able to pull this off for me. She also makes me crave a word processer where I can control-f for gerunds. That would make my life way easier.
Acknowledgements II: Thanks to wayland and Ariel for being great alpha readers, as well as sounding boards during this update’s stupidly long incubation. Bonus props to wayland for her constant nagging, without which I would never have made a public and irresponsible promise about getting this done in time for Christmas.
It’s been a while, and the first scene is primarily a flashback, making this terribly confusing. Let me take a moment to re-establish the timeline. 4.1 and the topless adventures that ended in Willow freaking out was Wednesday. Faith woke up from her coma on Friday. The events of 4.2 took place on Saturday. 4.3 begins after the meeting at Giles’, also on Saturday. Got it? Good.Chapter 4 Part 3: ExperimentingWillow stared critically into the mirror for a long moment. Finally, pleased with what she saw, she nodded decisively.
“Yep. I look totally hot,” she announced to her empty dorm room.
For your date. She frowned at the unwelcome, if internal, commentary. “This is totally not a date.”
Dancing? Bronze? The company of someone you want to see naked? Totally a date. “Listen here, missy.” Willow shook her finger at her reflection in the mirror. “There may be date-ish qualities in play, but this is not a date.”
Which is why you carefully picked out a low-cut version of the shirt you were wearing in the laundry room for a top? Or why your skirt is one that reminds you of the one you had on the first time you kissed her? Sounds like date wardrobe to me. “They’re Bronze clothes, thank you very much. I wore Bronze clothes to go there with Buffy. Those weren’t dates.”
And when you hoped to run into Xander? Willow rolled her eyes. “Those weren’t dates either.”
But you wanted them to—“I’m warning you. You want to drop that subject right now.”
Fine, fine. I give. Willow almost expected her reflection to lift her arms in surrender.
“Good.”
I mean, it's obvious. You’ve carefully picked your outfit to look hot for a girl. You've spent the entire day considering said girl as a potential sexual partner - all being completely orthogonal to whether or not you asking said girl to go dancing with you is a date. “Darn skippy it is. Orthogonal, I mean.”
On that note, how’s your list coming? Willow slid her hand into her left pocket, and her memories raced to the previous night as the tips of her fingers touched a slip of paper.
Willow woke with a start, the pounding of her heart loud in her ears and her breath hard and fast. Not instantly sure where she was, or why she lay on her back in the dark, instinct took over.
run.program(Danger!DangerWillRosenberg!)
Immediate threat detected Y/N?
N->GoTo Next
Proximal threat detected Y/N?
N->GoTo Next
Buffy nearby Y/N?
N->Increase Concern. GoTo Next
Evaluate(location)
Bed. Dorm room. Stevenson Hall. UaC Sunnydale.
Evaluate(probability(incoming.danger)given(location))
Low->GoTo End
Relax and assess
No longer concerned a vampire was in striking distance, Willow took the time to look around the room and try to remember what was going on. She seemed to be safe and sound in her bed. Her eyes strained in the dimly-lit room at the clock. 2:37. The room was dark: it must be 2:37 a.m. Nighttime.
That’s right. It was Friday night. Buffy wasn’t in her bed, which was bad; she was usually back from patrolling by now. No, wait. Riley had gotten out of the hospital today. Buffy was gone because she left the Scooby meeting with him. To explain who Faith was.
Faith.
If her brain could spit, it would have spat the name.
As the world came into focus, she realized her body hadn't calmed down any from her earlier panic. Though she didn’t instantly recall it, her lingering physical reaction was enough to tell her what it was. It must have been quite a nightmare: probably the one about Faith holding her at knife-point while throwing Buffy off the top of a building. Not something she wanted to remember anyways.
Willow pulled Mr. Snuggle Pupkins close, and moved to turn over. She had heard in psychology that a change in physical position decreased the likelihood of returning to the same dream.
“What the . . . ?” As Willow shifted in the bed, her attention snapped instantly to between her legs. “See, damp underwear is not a post-scary dream reaction. It's a post . . . wait a second.” Willow strained to remember what it was she had actually dreamt. And the moment she did, the moment she stopped to think instead of simply assuming, one thought filled her mind.
Tara.
Willow reached for the details of the dream, but the harder she worked to get them back, the faster they left. She was left with a blurred picture of the idea of being naked in bed with Tara, although she lacked any sense of what it would be like or what she would do once she got there. But like an Impressionist painting, the blurry picture in her mind certainly had an emotional effect: she was really turned on.
Willow's first thought was that her replacement psychology professor had been right about emotions being labels for physiological states, as she'd managed to confuse being horny and being terrified. Second came surprise; despite how fast the physical aspects of her friendship with Tara had developed, an erotic dream about her felt totally out of the blue. Finally, the begging and the pleading of her body to please take care of this caught her attention.
Though Willow generally resented her body when it made demands (because seriously, wasn’t it supposed to be subservient to her?), the idea sounded good. Really good.
As she gently tossed Mr. Snuggle Pupkins to the floor (so he faced the wall, of course), Willow took a deep breath. It had been a long time since she'd done this: she'd completely lost interest in masturbation since Oz had left. But now . . . now it felt like the best idea ever.
Slowly, she began to undo the buttons of her pajama top as she remembered how she'd done the same to Tara's shirt Wednesday night. The sounds Tara had made filled her head once more, and spurred her to work the buttons faster. When the top was finally open, Willow ran her fingers slowly down the line she'd paved with kisses along Tara's chest. As she reached her navel, Willow smiled as she remembered Tara's encouragement.
Willow let her hands drift back up to her breasts and cupped them gently. Even after such a short time exploring Tara's body, her own breasts didn't feel quite right. She liked the weight and the curve of Tara's breasts far better; they felt right in her hands. So instead of focusing on her memory of touching Tara, she instead focused on what it had felt like for Tara to touch her. The effect was instantaneous: a larger wave of arousal crashed through her.
As she played with her breasts, she avoided her nipples, instead she moved her fingers closer and closer and then, when they brushed areola, she moved them out and away again. After a few rounds of this teasing, she gave in and finally brushed her nipples with her fingertips.
She quietly groaned at the touch, impressed to discover how hard they felt after all the near misses. Impatient, she wet the thumb and forefinger of each hand before she pinched the stiff nipples, all the while remembering the feel of Tara's mouth on them. With the splendid combination of lips, tongue, and teeth, Tara had done the most amazing things to her.
Teeth. Willow shook her head in amazement. Teeth had to be kept strictly off the table with Oz. The risk was too great. There had been a few times with Xander when Willow had melted as teeth sank into her skin, but she’d always thought that it was because what they were doing was forbidden that caused such excitement. But Tara had provoked such a strong reaction, even just biting the soft inside of her wrist, or nipping the pads of her fingertips.
Thoughts of Tara smiling, Willow’s fingers between her teeth, were tantalizing enough to pull one of Willow’s hands down to her waist. She pushed her hand along the skin of her abdomen, under the waistband of her pajama bottoms. However appealing it was to become directly involved with the urgent need between her legs, she knew from her experience that it was much faster to take a more circuitous route.
Willow remembered the first time she had done this. Curious as to what all the fuss was about, she’d explored this part of her body slowly, carefully. The skin on her abdomen was delicate and sensitive. She’d been so surprised to discover that gently running her fingers through the hair she found there, like that, could feel so exciting, rather than how it felt when she ran a washcloth over it.
Her first attempts to understand had involved a more direct route. She knew the anatomy of her body well enough to know generally where her hand was supposed to end up. But those early endeavors left her confused, frustrated, and sore. At the same time, it was a project she couldn’t bear to give up. She knew that there was a key in there somewhere, and when she found it, the door she opened up would be a good one.
It was accident that taught Willow to detour her hand to her inner thighs as her next step, and subsequent trial-and-error that taught her to pull her hand back outside her underwear and press her wrist into her groin as she fingered the soft skin of her legs. By now she knew how to pace the bucking of her hips up against her arm.
Not until she could feel her own wetness, soaked through to the skin of her wrist, did Willow bother to return her hand to beneath her underwear. She fingered the wiry hair she found there once more, but only briefly, before she reached down to stroke her outer lips. The contact, so familiar and yet so long filed away, made Willow gasp. As she ran her fingers up and down, she remembered lying in Tara’s bed, topless, stroking Tara’s face: her cheeks, her eyelids, and eventually her lips.
But Tara had objected, saying that the fingers along her lips tickled. So Willow had shifted, and had run her tongue along the length of Tara’s mouth. Without pressing in, she swept along the seam between Tara’s lips, and the thought made her run a finger along her slit. It told her just how wet she was, how ready her body was to press forward. Willow dipped her finger down between her lips, coating it in wetness before sliding it up to her clit.
Tara.
It was thoughts of Tara that brought her to this state: the expressiveness of her eyes, the softness of her lips, the taste of her skin. Those same thoughts continued to fill her mind as she moved her finger in a pattern of circles and strokes she had known long before that first exploration: 0, 1, 10, 11, 100 . . . .
Soon, Willow felt her hips jerk: this wasn’t going to take long. So much time had passed, and it felt so very good. Her finger moved faster, in a pattern stored in muscle memory, as she remembered the smoothness of Tara’s stomach beneath her tongue and the smell of vanilla on her skin. Then memories from later: the top of Tara’s underwear against her tongue and the smell of Tara’s arousal through her skirt.
Willow’s muscles began to tense. It always began in her legs, for some reason. The feeling spread rapidly enough, and soon it felt as though her whole body was connected by wires to her clit, and every circle around it tightened the wires a little more. As they became impossibly tight, Tara’s eighth happy noise--the low, throaty growl--rang in Willow’s head.
The wires snapped.
Willow never knew how long it took for her brain to turn back on after she came, and tonight was no different. The first thing she always noticed, when she was alone, anyway, was the steady pulse below her finger. It always felt terribly slow. She was always too content to care, though, too happy to bask in the primal satisfaction of her afterglow, to do anything but feel the rhythmic movement. For a while, at least.
The final gears in Willow’s brain finally caught, and her eyes snapped open. She moved to stretch, pausing to wipe her fingers on her lower abdomen before pulling them out of her pajama bottoms.
“Wow. Okay, totally needed that.” Willow looked up at her ceiling. “And, with the timing, after Tara said . . . .” Willow blushed in the darkness. Not that, you know, doing that while thinking about her means that we should . . . you know . . . right away. Just that, maybe what I said about eventually getting caught up in the touching could mean a sooner ‘eventually’ than a later one.”
Willow recalled the conversation from the other night, and suddenly felt sick.
“Only, she didn’t say that. She didn’t say she wanted to sleep with me. She said that she would if I wanted to . . . that's not wanting to, that’s acquiescing to.” Willow jumped out of bed, feeling the beginnings of panic. “And see, that’s not okay. I can’t . . . I mean, I offered to Oz when . . . and he knew enough to turn me down. If she agreed because I wanted, and then I . . . .” Willow began to pace. “No. No, no, no, can’t do that. That would be bad. That would be wrong.”
Willow caught the smell on her hand as she paced, and she looked at it in horror. “No, I just . . . .” She looked from her hand to her bed and back again. “Bad. Bad, bad, with the me and the . . . and the thinking about Tara, and now I’m going to put pressure on her and . . . no.”
She rushed to the cabinet below the sink and began to knock bottles out of the way until she found the GoJo, the soap Buffy kept around for getting off demon goo. Once she had poured a good amount onto her hand, she began to scrub.
“C’mon, c’mon, go away, please, gotta fix this.” Willow knew that with the amount of soap she’d dispensed, the room should smell like oranges, but instead it just reeked of sex. It just made her scrub her hand harder. As she washed her hand, she looked at herself in the mirror, saying, “Bad, bad, bad.”
A sudden, sharp sting made Willow cry out and look down at her hands. Between the brush and the pumice in the soap, she had torn a hole in her skin. As she rinsed the soap out of the wound and dried off her hands, she forced herself to calm down.
“Okay, me, going all Lady MacBeth over this is not going to help anybody. I’m busy being freaked-out gal about something that might happen, not something that has happened. I just need to make sure that badness doesn’t happen.”
Willow settled into the chair at her desk; she could always think at a desk. She reached for a notebook, so she could try to organize her thoughts, but found a post-it note on the top page, and a hand-printed translation on the adjacent notebook paper.
January 25
Confirmed: Willow’s straight. Stop crushing on her before you lose control and do something stupid that costs you a friend.
Naughty thoughts are not welcome. Please stop now.
“That’s right. I got that translation spell. I wonder if seeing this before bed is why I . . . .” Willow shook her head. “But, does it mean she wants to . . . I mean, lots of things could count as naughty. This was before the kissing. Maybe that’s what she meant, just thinking about kissing me. In a certain context, she could think that would be naughty. But maybe she meant . . .” Willow gulped. “Maybe she wanted to. Even then. All that time ago.”
Willow hit her head against her desk a few times. “Dammit. I can’t tell what she means, not exactly. And I need exactly.” She sighed. “I could hurt her really badly if I don’t know exactly.”
It took a moment, but Willow realized. She needed to ask. But that wasn’t all. Because if Tara did want to . . . well, Willow needed to know if she, too, was ready. She’d seen things go so poorly with Parker, she needed to make sure that if she and Tara took that step, that it wasn’t a mistake. Needed to protect Tara, even though she didn’t seem to realize she needed protection, just like Oz had done with her.
So Willow began to write.
Willow clenched her hand around the paper in her pocket. “Just about done, actually.” It had been a long day, full of a lot of awkward moments, but Tara had gone along. More than that, she seemed happy.
Sounds like a pretty happy ending for your date. “Look, just . . . shut up. I’m going to go take Tara dancing, but it won’t be a date.”
Well, why not? “Because . . . .” Willow sighed. “Look, taking Tara on a date would mean thinking about if we’re dating, which would mean thinking about if Oz and I are dating, which would mean thinking about Oz, and right now I just want to think about celebrating Faith being gone. So you, missy, are going to shut the hell up, and I’m going to Tara’s. So there.” She glared at the mirror a final time, and did her best to leave insecurities there with it.
***
Willow knocked on Tara’s door and bounced eagerly on the balls of her feet. She had just begun to wonder if she should have called first when the door opened.
“Hey, you’re back.” Tara looked Willow up and down, a pleased expression on her face. She didn’t look surprised, though, as if she’d grown accustomed to Willow randomly appearing on her doorstep. “And, um, you’ve changed. Again.” She stepped back into the room and waved Willow in.
Willow followed Tara into the room, a wide smile on her face. Without planning it, she picked Tara up and spun her around in a circle. “Faith’s gone!” Once Willow put her down, Tara opened her mouth but before she could say anything, Willow kissed her. All of the stress and fear she’d pushed into a little corner melted away, and all her focus was on the singular task of kissing Tara like it was the most important thing in the world.
A long moment later, Willow pulled back and looked at Tara seriously. “You’re safe,” she said softly as she brushed Tara’s cheek with the back of her hand.
Tara tilted her head to the side, a questioning look on her face. “Of course I am. Why wouldn’t I be?”
“Faith tends to hurt the people I care about the most.” Willow kissed Tara’s forehead. “That category includes you.”
Tara beamed, and the sight lit Willow up inside. Seeing Tara happy was just so rewarding. Willow couldn’t help but think how close her mind was to agreeing to a whole new category of ways to make Tara happy. She felt the blush rise in her cheeks, but forced herself to keep her eyes on Tara.
“So, what’s with the new clothes? Did you slip, you know, again?”
“Well, Faith’s gone, meaning the Scoobies are victorious. A trip to the Bronze is traditional.” Something flickered across Tara’s face, but Willow wasn't sure what it was. Still, it made her nervous, so she dropped her gaze to her fidgeting fingers before she continued. “So, um, wouldyouliketogodancingwithme?”
Don’t ask “Like a date?” Don’t ask “Like a date?” Willow chanted to herself until she realized that Tara wasn’t asking. In fact, Tara wasn’t saying anything at all.
Oh god. What if she says no? Willow hadn’t even considered it.
Desperate, she retreated, all the while staring at her nervous hands. “I mean, it’s totally okay if you don’t want to go. Why would you want to? It’s a stupid idea. Forget I--”
Willow found herself caught up in a kiss. It was exciting and passionate. Within seconds it had banished all thoughts of the Bronze, of leaving the room, and of doing anything but casting aside the rest of her stupid checklist and giving in to the tremendous physical need to move forward. Sensing weakness, her body moved of its own accord: her hands found their way to Tara’s shoulders, down her back, and were about to slide under Tara’s waistband when Tara pulled back.
“I’d love to go dancing with you.” Tara hugged Willow close, and squeezed away any thoughts of suggesting they simply stay here. She couldn’t go back on her offer. Not now. Not when Tara looked so excited.
“Good.” Willow nodded, mostly to convince herself. “Good.” With Tara no longer kissing her, Willow’s brain pressed back: she had to do this right. There was an order these things had to go in. Revising that order with the bed so close and Tara’s hands so soft around her waist was a terrible idea, like going grocery shopping when hungry. Only much, much worse.
“I’m guessing, then, that I’m not appropriately dressed?” The question pulled Willow back towards the moment, but it wasn’t quite enough.
“Hmm?”
“Well, you changed, and you said it was to go to this Bronze place . . . ?”
“Oh! Right! Yeah, clothes. I suppose, yeah, those aren’t really Bronze clothes, are they?” Willow frowned. “Man, I really am just helping you pile up dirty laundry today, aren’t I?”
Tara smiled. “Oh, I think it’s worth it.” Tara took Willow by the hand, and guided her over to the closet. “So, see anything you like?”
The lead-up was too perfect and Willow’s desire was too great for her to resist. She stepped behind Tara and reached around to cup her breasts as she whispered, “I like you.”
Willow heard Tara's sharp intake of breath, and felt her melt backwards into Willow and push her chest forward. "I'm glad." She turned in Willow's arms and kissed her. "I like you, too." Tara squeezed Willow quickly before turning back to her closet. "But I was asking about clothes, silly."
Clothes. Changing. Suddenly Willow remembered their interactions before dinner, and grew stiff. It had all gone terribly wrong: Tara had freaked out and withdrawn. What had she done wrong? Was it not okay to look? Should she leave when Tara changed this time? As she pointed at shirts and skirts that would be appropriate for the Bronze, part of her brain splintered off to formulate excuses for leaving Tara alone to change.
“So, um, yeah, any of those should be good.” Willow took a deep breath and kissed Tara’s neck. “How about you do the changing thing, and I’ll do the bathroom thing and you can meet me in the hallway when you’re done?” Willow gave Tara a quick squeeze and stepped back.
Tara turned quickly and caught Willow’s hands, looking slightly concerned. “Are-are you okay?”
“Fine.” Willow smiled weakly. “I’m good, just . . . had too much to drink at Giles’. I’ll meet you outside?”
Tara’s face relaxed and she nodded. “Cool. I’ll just be a minute.”
“Yeah, me too.”
Willow headed out of the room and down the hall to the restroom, where she immediately grabbed a sink and leaned over it as uncertainty won over. Willow replayed the incident from the afternoon in her head. It should have been fun and sexy and tempting. It should have been a chance to show Tara she wanted things to go further.
Would it have been different if she’d asked for Tara’s help earlier? She’d certainly intended to ask Tara to help her before Tara put on clean clothes, only to be silenced by the distressed look on her face. How had admiring Tara pushed her away? In the past it had always delighted her.
Willow shook her head. Tara had agreed to go the Bronze, and she should focus on that. She could go, secure in the knowledge that her friends were decidedly elsewhere, and relax into the idea of being there with Tara. They could talk, dance, and have a good time. In fact, she remembered suddenly, given who usually tended bar on Saturdays, they could also have amaretto sours. Of course, she had no idea if Tara drank at all, or was comfortable with underage drinking in general. Though, she hadn't said anything about the hacking, which was way more illegal.
Then there was what Xander and Buffy would say if they found out . . . when did going to the Bronze get so freaking complicated?
Start by offering her a soda, then later, depending on things are going, say you could get her a harder drink, if she wanted. “Okay, me. We're good. We have a plan. Let's do this.” As Willow pulled her hands off the edge of the sink, she realized how sweaty her palms were. She was nervous. Why was she nervous? Tara was familiar. The Bronze was familiar. Nothing to be nervous about.
Except the list in your pocket. Except that almost everything is crossed off. Willow carefully washed her hands, this time without excessive scrubbing or blood drawing.
As Willow left the restroom, she looked down the hallway and spotted Tara locking her room, and it stopped Willow in her tracks. Tara's wardrobe had always intrigued Willow: so distinctly feminine, yet at the same time so very different from, say, Buffy's. But that fascination didn't quench her reaction to Tara's current attire. When she had suggested Tara wear that skirt, she hadn't realized the floral print would wrap around to the back like that.
And by back, you mean ass. At which you are now staring. Tara turned to face Willow, but she couldn’t help but continue to stare. Willow's eyes swept slowly up. She felt a small shiver go down her spine as Tara's top registered: Tara always looked amazing in green. Finally, her eyes caught that Tara had put a choker back on, the one with the three metal pieces in the front. All at once, all Willow could think about was Tara lying on top of her, topless, as Willow took those metal beads in her mouth and between her teeth.
“Are we a codfish?” Tara asked, her head tilted and a curious expression on her face. Willow blinked, not understanding. Tara opened her mouth, and then mimed shutting it with a finger to her chin.
Willow realized in horror that she had been staring, open mouthed, at Tara. She snapped her jaw shut. “We are not a codfish.”
Tara grinned. “Good to hear.” She paused. “Is everything okay?”
Willow opened her mouth to dismiss her odd behavior before thinking better of it. With a quick glance down the hallway, Willow could see that no one was paying them any mind. Still, she found herself looking at the floor when she said softly, “You look really nice.”
Tara's initial response, a small, delighted noise, made Willow's heart pound faster in her chest. In her field of view was Tara's hand, and Willow felt the sudden need to take it; she paused, however, before her hand so much as twitched. Holding her hand out here, outside of the cocoon of Tara's room, was at once compelling and daunting. Willow knew the feel of Tara's hand, and how electrifying that softness could be. At the same time, it, combined with taking Tara dancing at the Bronze, checked off the last of her list. Under the harsh flickering lights of the dorm hallway, the thought of being done with it and crossing the subsequent threshold . . . the enormity of the thing got to her. It felt like driving too fast down the mountains, not sure the car would stay under control.
Willow pulled her gaze up away from the temptation of Tara’s hand to find her head shyly tilted down, but a bright smile on her face. As she looked into Tara’s eyes, so full of joy, Willow realized something. She’d thought about her list completely wrong. It wasn’t a brick on the accelerator, meaning she had to do anything she wasn’t ready to do. It was there to be the brakes, to keep her from acting too soon. Willow wanted to hold Tara’s hand . . . and that was okay. It didn’t mean anything more than that, not if she wasn’t ready for it.
Some of the self-imposed weight lifted off Willow’s shoulders, and she smiled at Tara. “Come on,” she said as she nodded down the corridor. As they turned and began to walk, Willow pulled her bottom lip between her teeth and took a deep breath before she reached out and took Tara’s hand.
Willow felt Tara jump beside her and almost dropped her hand, suddenly worried she had been too forward. But before she could, Tara squeezed her hand tightly. Still not sure what to expect, Willow smiled shyly, and turned slowly to look at her.
The look on Tara’s face was one Willow had seen before. The bright eyes and the slightly parted mouth that slowly turned up into a smile spelled out delight and glee as surely as if the words had been written out in ink. Having that smile, that look, directed at her was warming, and reminded Willow of turning her face to the sun on a chill winter day. Tara looked at her like that, and Willow knew that was she was wonderful.
What eventually struck Willow, though, was that it was an expression she had only seen on Tara’s face in private. Like the action that caused it, it was from a part of their lives previously confined to Tara’s room. Willow felt that look hit her, and shivered.
“Hi.” Willow heard herself say the word, though she didn’t know why she had said it. She felt stupid; why had she let something so out of place slip out of her mouth?
“Hi yourself.” Tara shook her head gently, but her smile persisted. She sounded amused, like Willow had said something clever and appropriate, not completely inane. “Do you, um, w-want to keep going to the Bronze? Or do you want to stand in the hallway staring at each other like a couple of l-lovestruck teenagers?”
“Bronze, please.” As they began to walk again, Willow continued, “But we are a couple of teenagers. You know, technically. At least, for a little while, yet.” She knew she was being ornery, but being correct was important.
“For a while, yet.” There was a sad, faraway sound to Tara’s voice, and when she spoke, she squeezed Willow’s hand tightly. Concerned, Willow looked over to try to read Tara’s face, but a curtain of hair hung in her way. For a moment, she opened her mouth to speak, but found she didn’t know what to say.
As they made their way out of Hillcrest in silence, Willow replayed the moment over and over again. What happened to make Tara sound so distant? All she had done was point out that they were, in fact, still teenagers. And they were. They corrected each other all the time; it was habit, it was banter. It was play.
Something to do with getting older, perhaps? That Tara’s mother wouldn’t have the chance to watch Tara go to college, graduate, and grow into an adult? That leaving her teens would mark a threshold that Tara passed without her mother? Willow knew, for her own part, that her birthdays had been tinged with sadness in the past few years: it was one of the few times of the year she really felt that Jesse was gone. The reality was that life as a Scoobie meant facing that people die on a day to day basis, but Jesse was not only the her first experience watching someone become a vampire, he was also her friend. Distant as her relationship with her parents was, Willow couldn’t imagine them not seeing her graduate, not seeing her get married, not doing all those landmark things she had in front of her. So of course it made sense that Tara would be saddened by the thought of leaving her teens, and moving on into a new decade of her life that her mother would never see.
When they finally made their way into the cool evening, Tara paused and looked at Willow, an expectant look on her face.
“What’s up?”
“I don’t know the way. I have to follow you, but you’re not, um, leading.”
“Oh. Heh. Right.” Willow tugged on Tara’s hand, and pulled her to the right. After months at school, Willow knew the best-lit routes through campus. “This isn’t the most direct way,” Willow said as they made a left turn. “But it is bright. So, it’s not how you would go during the day. There’s a much more direct route. Of course, not that you would go to the Bronze during the day. It’s not even open. Just, you know, with Buffy, we’d go a different way.”
“R-right. I don’t mind taking a longer route.” Tara ran her thumb across the back of Willow’s hand. “Walking is nice, and the company is great.”
“Aw, shucks.” Willow bumped her shoulder gently into Tara’s. “You’re so sweet.” Though she didn’t plan on it, Willow felt her own thumb move on Tara’s hand. She had noticed, across the past week, that she was never content to touch Tara and leave her hand still; rather, she needed the feel of skin sliding against skin. It had never been this way with Oz, certainly not simply holding hands. Contact with Tara was necessary but not sufficient.
They spoke only occasionally during the bulk of the walk, though the bouts of silence were amicable. Willow had to temper her desire to immerse herself in the experience of being with Tara, a desire fueled by the warm softness of Tara’s hand. Instead, she kept a constant eye on the shadows. Buffy was out tonight, but her target was Adam, not vampires. Their safety, then, fell onto Willow’s shoulders. Tara had never had to develop the eye for predators in the dark, the feel of being actively hunted. It would be terribly poor form, in the face of victory over Faith, to be sloppy in the constant vigilance against the mundane undead.
“Look!” Willow pointed. “That’s us, right there.”
“It, um, looks like a warehouse.”
“That makes sense: it actually used to be one. Or, I guess you could say that it still is one. It’s just, now the wares that it houses are booze, bands, and . . . Some b-word that means ‘teenagers.’”
In the light from the Bronze, Willow spotted one of Oz’s friends. Without thinking, she promptly dropped Tara’s hand. It wasn’t until the cool air hit her warmed skin that Willow realized what she had done. In an effort to make her move look less like she was embarrassed, she pointed towards the door with that hand. “They only charge cover when they have live music. No one’s at the door, so they must just be playing CDs over the sound system.” They approached the door, and Willow looked over at Tara. She held her arms crossed over her chest. Willow had seen her do that enough to know it was indicative of Tara pulling in on herself.
Great, just great. I get her to the Bronze all happy-like, and now she’s going all shy because I’m jumping at shadows of Oz? “Can they get decent acoustics, being a warehouse and all?”
“Right, you’ve never been inside. I keep forgetting. It’s just . . . I can't believe you've never been here. The Bronze is the coolest place in Sunnydale.” Willow aimed for funny and charming in an effort to pull Tara back out of her shell. “Course, not a lot of competition there . . . I think the vending machine at Burgin's came in second.”
“Y-you used to come here a lot?” Tara sounded surprised.
Willow looked around, breathing in the familiarity of the Bronze. “Lived here. Me, Xander, . . .” her mood crashed as her eyes landed on someone she did not want to see, “. . . Buffy.”
Watching Buffy taunt some random frat boy chugging a beer left Willow speechless for a minute. Buffy wasn’t supposed to be here. She was supposed to be hunting Adam. Maybe sleeping with Riley. She was supposed to be anywhere but here.
“Wow, I didn’t think she’d be here.”
Suave, Willow. Of course you didn’t. You wouldn’t have brought Tara here if you did. Not that she knows that. So, decision time. Are you going to face this, or run like a coward and make Tara feel bad? Willow reached up and took Tara’s hand. “Come on. I want you to meet her.” Tara mattered to her, and that meant that she should meet her friends. The isolation from the rest of her friends had taken a toll on Tara, and that was wrong. It was time to fix all that.
The pleased look on Tara’s face was enough to send Willow to happy land as she turned to pull Tara through the crowd. All these things she had pushed herself to do really seemed to make Tara happy. They may have been a little hard, but Tara’s reaction continued to dwarf her sense of awkwardness or uncertainty.
Okay, going to bring Tara over to Buffy, and I’m going to say, ‘Hey, Buffy, this is Tara, my . . . .’ Willow faltered. What
was she going to say? It wasn’t enough to say that Tara was her friend. Tara was so much more than that. But what could she say? Tara was just, well,
Tara. She could just say that, that she was Tara. Which would be fine. Until, of course, Buffy noticed they were holding hands. Could she tell, with the slayerness and all, that it wasn’t the same kind of holding hands that she did with Buffy? Because if she could, she would ask things. Worse, she would ask things in front of Tara. Meaning Willow would have to answer in front of Tara. Then she would have to manage not just what Buffy thought, but also what Tara thought of what she was telling Buffy . . . .
Buffy pushed the frat boy away, and Willow decided that now was the time for baby steps, not to risk anything getting complicated. Things with Tara were confusing already, and the last thing she needed was to make it worse. Hoping Buffy had been too distracted to notice yet, she quickly dropped Tara’s hand. Soon enough, Buffy turned and walked right into them.
“Hey, Buffy!”
“Willow. And - uh . . .” Buffy paused, clearly waiting for an introduction.
“Buffy, this is Tara.” Simple. Not complicated. The situation was totally doable.
“Hi.” Tara sounded so small, against the background din of the Bronze and the confidence streaming off Buffy. This was a terrible idea.
“So we’ve never met?” Buffy asked Tara, who merely shook her head. “Okay. Cool. I’m having a thing with names.”
“Tara was in my Wicca group,” Willow said, trying to stave off any questions from Buffy that she’d have to answer in front of Tara.
“Uh huh.”
Sounds uninterested. Excellent. “So, what’s up?” Buffy walked toward a nearby couch, and Willow touched Tara’s arm before indicating an adjacent chair. Hopefully they would be rid of Buffy soon. However, the way Buffy dropped herself into the couch didn’t exactly scream ‘temporary.’
Dammit, woman, way more of a settling-in type action that I wanted to see out of you right now. “Patrol a no-go?” continued Willow, who desperately wanted to keep the conversation away from her and Tara. She needed to find some way of subtly encouraging Buffy to leave. But Buffy kicked her feet up onto the table, further reinforcing she was here to stay. When Tara took a seat, Willow sat on the arm of the chair, the socially acceptable distance between them suddenly feeling like a gulf.
“I got tired. The whole Faith thing . . . I wanted to let off some steam.”
“Good for you. You shouldn’t work yourself too hard.”
In fact, you should go let off some of that steam with Riley. Work him hard. Right now. Shoo. “That’s my philosophy.” Buffy threw her arms behind her head.
Great, just great. First I chicken out and drop Tara’s hand, and now I’ll just have to sit next to Buffy looking all cool and way more attractive than me and Tara will figure out I’m just a dork with a cool friend. Willow needed out. Now. “Anyone want a soda?” At least this way she could be chivalrous for Tara, without being too obvious.
Tara looked up at her. “Water?” Buffy shook her head, and Willow went over to the bar to fetch.
Perfect. Just perfect. I finish off my checklist just in time to show Tara how much of an insecure spaz I am. Willow looked around the club, checking to see if anyone else was there that would disrupt her original ‘take Tara dancing’ plans. If she could get rid of Buffy fast enough (she should just give in and
mention Riley; that should work), maybe she could just pull Tara into a quiet corner, and try to explain what had happened. Apologize for being spooked. Show her with a kiss or two that the problem was not knowing what to say to Buffy, not that she didn’t want to be out in public with Tara.
As she looked around, she didn’t see anyone she knew to interfere with her new plan. She did, however, see something much worse.
A vampire.