by CrazyTaraWitch » Sat Apr 28, 2012 4:16 pm
For the most part today has been awesome, so much so that I feel like an ungrateful jerk for complaining, but I keep getting bummed by the one sucky part of the day.
For the last several months, I've been a pretty active member of a very small (30ish members, but only 8-12 of us really active at any given time, and only about 6 of us that have been active most of the time since we created the group) facebook group of Doctor Who fans. It's a really supportive and friendly group, and though I stand out a bit there (cause most of the posts are about expressing attraction towards a few of the male characters) I've generally felt very welcome. Heck, I think I was the third member, plus one of the first admin. This rant may not make much sense to people that don't know a little about Doctor Who, but basically, there have been 11 Doctors, and they're not just different actors, they have different personalities, despite being more or less the same character. There have also been many, many Companions that have traveled with him, and many different head writers that have taken the show in different directions. Personally, I love all the Doctors, nearly all the Companions, and the majority of the directions the show has gone in, but I understand many fans don't feel the same, and I've always known that most of the members of this particular fan group don't like the current show-runner and Companions, and don't like the current Doctor as much as the previous two. It's generally not been an issue, because we're a pretty respectful group and the #1 rule is that we not diss any of the Doctors, plus we rarely get into deep discussions--we're more about having fun and keeping things light and silly, plus occasional rants or raves. Once, despite knowing that I was the only real River fan in the group, I posted a very rant-y post about annoyance over some very harsh attacks against her character in another group, and got some really supportive comments, especially from the head admin. So, recently I posted a Doctor/River short story I'd written, and I got overwhelmingly positive feedback, again with the head admin speaking up the loudest, this time with praise. I was surprised and touched by the level of interest and support from the group, considering no one who read the story ships the pairing. I've also seen occasional comments from the head admin stating that she loves 11, just not as much as 9 and 10 but he's still great. I think it's reasonable that I drew the conclusion that the head admin wasn't strongly against 11, or him being paired with River, though of course I knew that 10 is very much her favourite Doctor. Then yesterday she angrily posted an article she'd come across stating that 11 is better than 10, and said shit like that is why she posts so much about 10. Now, the fact is 10 is far more popular than 11; yes there are people who say 10 sucked, but I spend a lot of time in large fan groups (more, I'm fairly certain, than the head admin does) and I still see way more people saying 10 is the best ever. Granted I didn't care for the article because it gave bad support for the preference, but the head admin's attitude was what really got to me, because she seemed to be up in arms over the simple fact of someone preferring 11 to 10, and was acting like it happens all the fucking time when in reality 11-lovers are in the minority. Today she posted a link to her response (because, she said, she tries to "not play favourites" in the group), and I knew it was going to rant at people who diss 10 and probably talk about why he's the "best" Doctor and was prepared to get a little annoyed because I adore 10 and 11 pretty equally and hate to see either of them talked badly about, but I was not prepared for how vehemently she spoke out about every single aspect of the show since 11 took over, and talking about how she hated this Doctor and thought he was wooden. What really got to me was her saying that the 11/River relationship made her feel ill, because why the hell did she claim to love my story if she detests the pairing at the center of it?? Several of the other members professed strong agreement with her response, and now I feel like I really don't belong there. I don't really want to be part of a group where everyone hates on my favourite head-writer, my favourite Companion, and one of my favourite Doctors. On the other hand, it's the only fan group I have where I actually feel like a person, where I can post things and have people care, where everyone is friends and we just have fun. Until today, I loved the group, and I know most of the members (the head admin especially) want me there, but now I'm just pissed and I feel like I don't fit--nor want to--in a group that trashes aspects of the show I completely adore.