Ok, time for some incoherent ramblings, and idle speculation. (Sorry in advance for spelling, punctuation)I have a problem with this whole Tara dies scenario. Over the last 2 years, we have seen Tara grow into a young woman with incredible self-control and poise. One can clearly make an argument that Tara has been the most important Scooby of them all this year. She has been their rock, their shoulder to lean upon. Tara was the one person that Dawn could identify with. After the death of Joyce, Tara become the mother figurehead to Dawn…..much more so than Buffy. Who was the one person that Buffy felt she could go to with her worries over coming back wrong? Who did she tell about her “relationship” with Spike?
With that being said why spend so much time building up Tara’s character, only to have her killed? It makes no sense to me. I know a lot of you are saying that this is the only way that Willow can go all BlackMagic on us. I say that this isn’t the only way, it is only the EASIEST. In my opinion ME, Marti, or whom ever you want to hold responsible, are just being plain lazy.
They had the perfect chance to explore Willow’s use/abuse of black magic. They could have stretched her addiction story out for months. They had all the players in place. (i.e. Rack, Amy) What would have been better than seeing Willow being turned dark by these little gifts of Amy’s? We could see Willow slowly falling to the magic. Hell, you could even have a confrontation between BlackMagicWillow and the Scoobies. As for Willow’s redemption? Tara of course. That would have given the Tara/Willow relationship a whole new level.
OK OK, maybe not the best scenario, but it sure beats the senseless death of one the series most interesting characters.
They went and got me hoping for the one thing I never thought I would want to see. A reset.
Which brings me to another issue. Why would the Scoobies have to forget everything that happened because of a reset? We have already seen two wishes granted (The Wish and Older and Far Away).
Two wishes, and two different results when the wishes are broken. In The Wish Anya’s power is stripped from her, the wish is broken and everyone forgets. In Older and Far Away Halfrek breaks the wish she granted herself to escape the house, and everyone remembers.
I was just wondering…what if the reset does come down to Anya and her wish? How much control does a vengeance demon have over their wish once it is granted? Can they control who remembers and who don’t, if they end the wish themselves? Would it be possible for Anya to be standing over a dying Xander, amulet in hand, getting ready to smash it and sacrifice herself for the man she loves, but right before she does whispers “Remember me”? That way everyone would remember the choices they made, and have a chance to grow from them.
I know, just idle speculation. I just can’t help think that this series, which I dearly love, is headed for a fall.
Once again, here is hoping for a happy W/T season finale.
P.S. Sorry for bringing up the whole Amy thing again. I'm just trying to show that the whole death scenario could have been avoided